Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
  
An unattended questionnaire on caste in cricket
Delhi: B P Baloo, a Dalit cricketer, earned glory for India during the pre-independence period. But, the issue is why there are not many players from lower castes in the Indian team.
BABAJI PALWANKAR BALOO: not many cricket fans will be aware of this name. And, if I go ahead with this article without giving a brief background about him, then perhaps it will sound like talking in the national language of Timbaktoo. So, let me start with a brief introduction of Baloo.
 
He was a left-arm orthodox spinner, who played cricket for India from 1906 to 1920. Born in Dharwad in Karnataka, he was perhaps the first Dalit cricketer of India. With an exceptional ability to turn the ball both ways he managed to claim 179 wickets in his career. Now, for all those who are wondering what is so special about this cricketer from the Chamar caste, let me remind them that this was the time when caste discrimination was predominant in India. This was also the time when the British ruled the Indians and in many areas ‘dogs and Indians were not allowed’.
 
However, it was the sheer talent of Baloo that never allowed the upper castes to dominate him. Most of us are aware of the fact that Vinoo Mankad claimed 100 wickets in 1946 in England. But, we might not know that Baloo achieved the same feat in 1911 when he toured England. He ended the year with a total of 114 wickets at an average of 18.84.
 
Can you imagine a Dalit cricketer in the pre-independence era going to England and beating the English batsmen in their own game? Also, do not forget to take into account the limitations of training and grooming available in India compared to what the English got, who started playing the game much before us. Many believe that Baloo was an inspiration for Dr B R Ambedkar.
 
The name of Baloo, however, is not new to many. The author Ramchandra Guha has written a famous book A Corner of a Foreign Field: The Indian History on Baloo’s life. Another author, Boria Majumdar, has also covered the player’s life well in his writings.
 
Many questions came to my mind about Balo and caste in Indian cricket. In fact, I would have loved to get answers for some of my questions mentioned below from either Guha or Majumdar. But it is my bad luck that none of them were available for an interview with a citizen journalist . Hence, I pass on the entire set of unanswered questions to the intelligent web community.
 
Here they follow.
 
Question 1: Babaji Palwankar Baloo, played in 1906. He was a good player. But, amazingly, till date we can hardly count any other Dalit cricketer in the Indian cricket team. Is it because Dalits are still financially weak and cannot pay to get groomed for the competitive selection process or is there a hidden social bias against them?
 
Question 2 (a): Unlike old days when cricket field was a forte of the city-dwelling rich and mighty, we have seen a number of star cricketers emerging from smaller cities in recent days, namely Mahendra Singh Dhoni from Jharkhand, R P Singh from Rai Bareilly, etc. Even the ones coming from cities belong to the lower class. Does it show a shift in the Indian cricket from big cities to small towns and across classes? What effect does it have on the caste composition of the team?
 
(b): Is there a regional trend in caste in cricket? The cricketers from the south – Rahul Dravid, Anil Kumble and V V S Laxman – and MaharashtraSachin Tendulkar and Ajit Agarkar – are Brahmins and urban. The cricketers from the north – Virendra Sehwag and Harbhajan Singh – and smaller towns are either lower or middle caste Hindus or non-Hinus. Is caste hierarchy more rigidly placed in the south?
 
Question 3: All selectors in Tamil Nadu Cricket Board are Brahmins, and the most recent player to emerge from the state is Murli Karthik, who is also a Brahmin. Does it reflect a caste bias in cricket?
 
Question 4: Is it a mere coincidence that Sunil Gavaskar, Dravid, Sourav Ganguly, Kumble, Tendulkar, Laxman and many other stalwarts of the Indian cricket are Brahmins?
 
Question 5: Everytime there is a small town guy displacing a big-city Brahmin from a position of prominence, the Brahmin lobby in cricket gets furious. Sunil Gavaskar could not digest the success of Kapil Dev. Tendulakar had problems with Sehwag taking his opener’s slot. The initial success of Harbhajan Singh displaced Kumble from the team in situations where only one spinner is required, and it created some murmers of discontent in the Karnataka cricketing lobby. Is this cold war castist in character? 
 
Question 6: What can be the future trends in Indian cricket team with respect to caste and class of players across regions?
 
Question 7: Some writers have pointed out Baloo inspired Ambedkar, something that Ambedkar has acknowledged. Can there be more Ambedkars if there are more Baloos?
 
I will like to put a disclaimer here that my intentions are neither to engage the fanatic cricket fans in a brainless debate nor to point a finger to the worthiness of any of the big cricketers I have named. Rather, with this article, I just want to dig into the truth and find out if India is really free of caste bias. If yes, then why is it that the eleven-member team of our most popular sport is not big enough to fit in a Dalit member? Or, does the problem lie somewhere else?
 
I hope the answers will come from the reader in the form of comments to this article or as fresh articles.
COMMENTS (32)
Guest
Name
Email Id
Verification Code
Email me on reply to my comment
Email me when other CJs comment on this article
}
Sign in to set your preference
ASHISH
LIST OF ALL BRAHMAN CRICKETOR 1] Sachin Tendulkar 2] Rahul Dravid 3] V.V.S Laxman 4] Sourabh Ganguly 5] Sunil Gavaskar 6] Ravi Shastri 7] Anil Kumble 8] Suresh Raina 9] Rohit Sharma10] Dilip Vengsarkar11] Kris Shrikant12] Chetan Sharma13] Ishant Sharma14] Amit Mishrajfrf16] Murli Vijay17] Manoj Tiwary18] Rahul Sharma19] Cheteshvar Pujara 20] Pragyan Ojha21] Sreeshashant22] Murli Karthik23] Ravichandran Ashvin24] Ajit Agarkar25] Laxmipati Balaji26] Hrishikesh Kanitkar27] Javagal Srinath, 28] Vinoo Mankad 29] Ajit Wadekar, 30] G.R.Vishwanath, 31] EAS Prassana,32] Yashpal Sharma,,33] Manoj Prabhakar, 34] B Chandrashekar, 35] Dilip Doshi, 36] Sunil Joshi, 37] Venkatesh Prasad, 38] Ashok Malhotra 39] Dileep Sardesai, 40] Sanjay Manjrekar,41] ML Jaisimha,42] Sudhakar Rao, 43] TA Shekar 44] LSIVARAMAKRISHNAN45] Gundappa Ranganath Viswanath46] Lala Amarnath47] Madanlal48] Srinivas Venkataraghavan49] Ashok Mankad50] Mohinder Amarnath51] Parthasarathy Sharma52] Surinder Amarnath53] KIRTI AZAD54] Raju Kulkarni55] Gopal Sharma56] Chandrakant Pandit57] Ajay Sharma58] Sanjeev Sharma59] V. B.Chandrasekhar60] M.Venkataramana61] Subroto Banerjee62] Saurabh Tiwary63] Joginder Sharma64] Rohan Gavaskar65] Vijay Bharadwaj66] Gyanendra Pandey67] Laxmi RatanShukla68] Jatin Paranjpe69] Nilesh Kulkarni70] Sunil Joshi71] Utpal Chatterjee72] Prashant Vaidya73] Deep Dasgupta74] Sadagoppan Ramesh75] W.V. Raman76] B.K.V Prasad77] Laxman Sivaramakrishnan79] Tirumalai Srinivasan80] Khandu Rangnekar -81] Amol Muzumdar82] Suru Nayak83] Ajit Pai84] Madhav Mantri85] Bhavaraju Venkata Krishna Rao86] Hemant Kanitkar87] Pochiah Krishnamurthy88] Vijay Manjrekar89] Nana Joshi90] Shute Banerjee91] Montu Banerjee92] C. R. Rangachari
Sudheer
To those guys who have already replied, please read the article in full before you reply. Only a shallow, ill-read, and probably star-struck pan-Indian can be foolish enough to believe that reality in India (be it sports, movies, or politics) can be caste-free. It is the same brain that says that India is close to becoming a developed nation because it has more millionaires than it had a decade earlier. Get out of the cities and the neon-filled brains. Right now, a dalit is getting butchered because he/she dared to fall in love with an upper-caste. Right now, a dalit with talent is planning to quit his interest because he needs to feed (as in daily bread) his family. Right now, a dalit with exceptional talent is ignored because he(she) does not belong. And it is not just enough to really LOOK AROUND, one must also LOOK INSIDE. Are we the ones doing it? Or will we protest when we see an injustice like that? Have we ever given a realistic thought that such things could happen? Even the U.S. sports scene (I mean the glamorous kind) was not liberated from white supremacy until the William sisters and Tiger Woods came along? Agree? Let us talk caste again. How did SO MANY brahmins find their way into the sport? Why is football and other more physically demanding sports not getting the same attention? Why are kids from coastal regions(who literally swim with the dolphins) never able to make it to national/international swimming arena? Asking more questions might lead us closer to the truth...
Mariam
Email: mkone000@yahoo.com FROM MISS Mariam KONE ABIDJAN COTE D IVOIRE Dearest One, Based on your profile i am happy to request for your assistance and also to go into business partnership with you, i believe that you will not betaryed my trust which i am going to lay on you. I am Miss Mariam Kone ,22 years old and the only daughter of my late parents MR.and MRS MUSTAPHA KONE. My father was a highly reputable busnness magnet-(a cocoa merchant)who operated in the capital of Ivory coast during his days. It is sad to say that he passed away mysteriously in France during one of his business trips abroad year 12th.Febuary 2004.Though his sudden death was linked or rather suspected to have been masterminded by an uncle of his who travelled with him at that time. But God knows the truth! My mother died when I was just 4 years old, and since then my father took me so special. Before his death on Febuary 12th 2004 he called the secretary who accompanied him to the hospital and told him that he has the sum of Ten Million United State Dollars.(USD$10 000 000) left in a security company in a mettalic trunk box, but the security company didn't know the content because it was registered as family valuables personal for security reasons. I am just 22 years old and a university undergraduate and really don't know what to do. This is because I have suffered a lot of set backs as a result of incessant political crisis here in Ivory coast. The death of my father actually brought sorrow to my life. Sir,I am in a sincere desire of your humble assistance in this regards.Your suggestions and ideas will be highly regarded. Now permit me to ask these few questions:- 1. Can I completely trust you? 2. What percentage of the total amount in question will be good for you? Consider this and get back to me in my private mail address above this letter as soon as possible. Thank you so much Sincerely Yours, Mariam
An unattended questionnaire on caste in cricket
An unattended questionnaire on caste in cricket
Advertisement
merinews for RTI activists
In This Article
anil kumble
(147 Articles)
rahul dravid
(371 Articles)
sachin tendulkar
(786 Articles)
sourav ganguly
(223 Articles)
sunil gavaskar
(99 Articles)

Create email alerts

Total subscribers: 208818
Advertisement
Vibhav Kant Upadhyay
Vibhav Kant Upadhyay
Indian Super League Fixtures
Vibhav Kant Upadhyay japan visit
Vibhav Kant Upadhyay India Center
Vibhav Kant Upadhyay in Japan
Vibhav Kant Upadhyay in IJGPS
Vibhav Kant Upadhyay Japan
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.