Kapil Sibal has brought in the proposal of reforming the IIT entrance examination. He said that marks obtained by a student in Class 12 for IIT entrance along with an aptitude test would decide admissions into IITs and other engineering colleges.
UNION HUMAN Resource Development Minister Kapil Sibal is making news once again. Now, Sibal has said that marks obtained by a student in Class 12 for IIT entrance along with an aptitude test would decide admissions into Indian Institute of Technology (IITs) and other engineering colleges. But the directors of the seven IITs’ of the country feel that the existing system of examination should be continued with the marks in Class XII and aptitude test.
Kapil Sibal is interested in renovation of Indian Institute of Technology (IIT) entrance examination ie, Joint Entrance Examination (JEE) to discourage the coaching institutes, as he feels it is harming quality intake and other problem is that children appearing for multiple entrance examinations, which causes financial and psychological pressure on the children and their family. But the coaching produces results which are not only desirable, but an absolute necessity in today's environment; it is need of hour for students.
Question is that are you in favour of reforms in IIT entrance examination’s system? Earlier Minister talked about raising the required minimum of 60 per cent marks to at least 80 per cent in Class 12 for IIT entrance examinations. Why Union Minister is dragging country’s prestigious institutes in their reforming extravaganza? Why he is not ready to keep away IIT entrance examination from All India Engineering Entrance Examination (AIEEE) and all state levels engineering examinations? Idea of introducing marks obtained by a student in Class 12 and aptitude test for AIEEE, other engineering examinations is welcomed but he should not include IIT entrance examination in it for the shake of country’s pride.
He should see the education system at school level and know the fact that why in India students need coaching from coaching centres for the preparation of competitive examinations for science or arts subjects? First he should reform the education system so that students are able to appear in competitive examinations without any help from coaching centres. This will also help underprivileged students of society.
In my view, there is nothing wrong in the present IIT entrance examination system. They have special method to assess the students through examinations and their renowned professors’ draft difficult, tricky examination papers so that only bright students can solve it. Institutions try to grab the most intelligent students to maintain the standard of the institute and also maintain the institutes’ prestige in the process. I am in favour of reformation in higher and primary education where education itself has become profitable business. Quality is lost in the increase of quantity of professional institutions with quota system and politicisation but I still consider that existing system of IIT entrance examination is enough and best way of selecting students in the prestigious institute.
Your comment has been submitted to moderator for approval.
Our policy makers sit on top and make decisions without knowing the facts at the grassroots level. IIT-JEE in the present form is quite alright and no meddling or tampering is
as such required. Taking admissions into IIT on the basis of 12 marks is hilarious - the whole world knows that all Board exams test only rote memory and have a number of evaluation loopholes. And will that prevent coaching ? No - coaching will flourish even more to provide guidance for 12 exams which is far more easier ! Sibal just wants to sensationalise - he has as usual not done his homework well before announcing big-ticket reforms ! Save IIT from lawyers and politicians !
KAPIL SIBBAL the HRD Minister will damage the IIT image by changing the JEE exam pattern. It is also the conspiracy to stop the rural poor students to join IIT.