Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
  
Arrests over Facebook post: Freedom of expression in great peril
The arrest of two girls over posting and liking a comment on Facebook that questioned Mumbai shutdown after Shiv Sena chief Bal Thackeray's death, shows how intolerant some of our politicians, who owe their position to democracy, but do not want the netizens to enjoy their right to free speech the very democracy has given them, are.

IF SUCH people are allowed to have free run, the time is not far when the civil liberty will be in peril in our democratic country. The arrests, supposedly for creating "disharmony" for simply commenting on the three-day bandh -sponsored by the Shiva Sainiks in the memory of their revered leader Bal Thackeray - defies logic. 

How can such an innocuous comment lead to public disharmony? If just a criticism of somebody's actions amounts to creating disharmony, there can’t be any democracy. Shaheen Dadha and Renu Srinivasan, both aged 21, from Palghar were arrested on Monday after Dadha posted a Facebook status questioning the Mumbai shutdown after Thackeray's death and Renu 'liked' it.

The founder of Shiv Sena and his party are known for making disparaging remarks against others verbally and through writings. Their fulminations were targeted against everybody who didn’t subscribe to their views. Sometimes if they singled out minorities like Biharis and Muslims and at other occasions they would make cricket and films target of abuse and vandalism.

Recently, Thackeray's anti-Bihari comments and writings created fear and terror in the hearts of thousands of Biharis residing in the Mumbai but he was not arrested, not anybody remotely suggested that he should be put behind bars. Where was our 'Scotland Yard' (Mumbai Police) or Maharashtra Police then? In fact he was never arrested in his lifetime though he has always been instigating violence against some section of the society or the other. Why this alacrity on the Facebook comment now?

The main reason behind the swift action of Maharashtra Police officers, who have been found responsible for many a violent incidents, in and outside Mumbai, against the girls was that this time not a politician, but aam aadmi dared to say something against our ‘respected’ politician. So, this time punishment is mandatory. And girls, according to lawyer, were being punished for creating ‘enmity and hatred’ and using online speech is grossly offensive and of menacing character and insulting religious feelings or beliefs’. 

This shows that the political power is more powerful than our law. In this context, the arrest of Assem Trivedi, a cartoonist, is a case in point. Trivedi had drawn cartoons on corruption in our political fraternity. He too had posted his political cartoon on the Internet. To draw our revered leader's attention towards the definition of cartoonist, according to a dictionary, is a person who uses an established and iconic image, which his audience can understand and relate to and then add his personal opinion to it. A cartoon is supposed to be exaggerated. Charging an artist for sedation, which means leading and instigating the community towards violence is beyond reason.

Now, the question that arises here is: why each and every time the democratic rights are being snatched from the hands of aam aadmi? Why democratic rights each time are being turned against the people by the government? 

Even, one of the greatest critics has said: "Art is the reflection of society'. So does the artist Trivedi through his cartoons, what's so offensive in it. Each and every time the ball is in government's court but what about those hands, who had chosen them to govern? The government has each and every right to take action when the fingers are being raised against them. This is not the end of the tale to present one more shocking incident of worst of its kind is the arrest of a Kolkata professor after he did nothing more than forwarding an email with a political cartoon that poked fun of the west Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee.

Although our political leaders were condemning these incidents, but the question arises here: is this the only way out, or will this continue to happen in a nation where you are free to express? And what about the politicians, who routinely get away with vandalism and violence of the worst kind? 

Such institutionalised double standards must be put to an end. If we want to stop this violence, we must question these double standards. One way of doing this is to amend the current law, which does not have sufficient safeguards for privacy and freedom of speech, and the law being used as a tool of harassment. If politicians and political leaders can be praised for being forthright, surely ordinary people have the right too. In a democracy of 2.5 billion people and multiple religions, you will find bewildering spectrum of opinions. So, please somebody teach our political leaders how to laugh at themselves.

COMMENTS (8)
Guest
Name
Email Id
Verification Code
Smita Johns
I really do not agree with you Harish and If he was beloved for some people also he was Hitler for large number of people. so this is a nice article and you should agreeing with the writer.
harish
this is a fictious article, and its written ina wrong way, u cant comment like this to our beloved Bala saheb.....................................it can create rage
Shahdab Makin
Superb article. Yes i agree with you shubhra. Some politicians are actually like that.
Sagnik Bose
It has nothing to do with freedom of expression. Look into your Facebook wall and you will realize the full freedom of humiliating and hurting sentiments is there for every netizen - you can ANYTHING about ANYONE... no matter how derogatory it is, no matter how hurtful it is, no matter how insensitive it is. But when you hurt somebody more powerful than you or more rowdy than you or more connected than you (in this case Shiv Sena) then you need to get prepared for backlash. Any which ways the law about 'freedom of expression on internet' is not well defined in India - had it been, then probably many of us would have been in jail along with the Shiv Sainiks
Sumit
Don't worry about these trolls. It is their duty to criticise the informed opinion because they are unable to think beyond a certain level. You have raised the right question: why wasn't Thackeray arrested when all the life he has been pitting people against each other through his writings and speeches. His party Shiv Sena was raised as a street dog for Congress Party and even though their masters have changed but their job has remained same. If these girls were actually guilty, so was the Sena leader. Ask these trolls why SriKrishna Commission report - which indicted Thackeray for 92-93 riots was never implemented?
deepali
This comment has been removed by the moderator
amit
Do you knw the meaning of Citizen Journo! I think ur a muslim coz if you cant see the simple purpose of the post by those two idiots. They being muslim posted against a hindu leader for once think y it was only done by a muslim girl!! coz they wanted to spread danga in mumbai.
Ajay
This comment has been removed by the moderator
merinews for RTI activists
In This Article
bal thackeray
(121 Articles)
facebook
(887 Articles)
mamata banerjee
(520 Articles)

Create email alerts

Total subscribers: 205575
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.