Crabs cheer while foxes feast on baingan bharta
Enterprising farmers of Gujarat didn't wait for GEAC's approval to cultivate Bt cotton. They defied the 'ban', buying seeds from black market and prospered. After all farmers don't need babus and eco-activists to tell what is good for them.
THERE IS no disagreement at all that Bt brinjal (aubergine) is capable of resisting several insect pests. It increases yield of fruits substantially even while drastically reducing the use of pesticide.
Genetic Engineering Approval Committee, a body of scientists working for the Department of Biotechnology had conducted a review of results of field trials of the transgenic hybrid eggplant developed by Mahyco, a subsidiary of global seed giant Monsanto. GEAC could only satisfy itself that broadly indicated standard procedures were followed for trials. The DOB obviously does not possess the resources to conduct research involving huge development costs. The MNC giant, on the other hand, could attract and retain talented scientists- several of them Indians – and provide them the facilities they needed.
GEAC recommended to the government in October 2009, that Bt brinjal could be commercially released. Four months and several tumultuous, highly publicised consultation meetings later, Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh has announced a 'moratorium' on its 'commercial release'.
Although trials proved that cotton crop worth millions could be saved from the dreaded weevil infestation dependably even while drastically reducing pesticide costs, clearance was held up for four years. By the time the Central government formally released it, enterprising farmers, particularly in well-off states like Gujarat, had taken their own decision about cultivating the variety.
As happens in any market, bureaucratic prohibition on advanced technology was circumvented. The stakeholders can’t afford to wait indefinitely as it may take decades to address all safety issues. Even as the minions of GEAC threatened to burn their ‘illegal’ crop, a couple of successful crops were harvested. The farmers didn’t mind paying black-market rates for seeds because the savings in pesticides far exceeded the extra cost.
The pesticides lobby, whose survival is threatened while the farmer prospers by opting BT crops, understandably, has vested interest in delaying adoption. The other vested interests benefiting from the prohibition are black market traders of seeds. Eco-terrorists operating from posh offices and shuttling in air-conditioned cars derive wide publicity from their budgets, but the farmers know what is good for them.
Incidentally, Union ministers of environment, agriculture and science and technology and the Prime Minister's office have openly supported immediate release. Obviously, the company has already taken care of their concerns.
Just like almost 80 per cent of cotton from India today is under Bt variety, it can be safely predicted that the ‘moratorium’ can’t last long with regard to other crops. Possibly, farmers will stop cultivating fringe varieties of eggplants in three to four years.
Gujarat's share of aubergine production, currently around 12 per cent of India's consumption, may have tripled by the time the formal clearance comes. Till then, pesticide manufacturers will get a breather for survival in other states. Bureaucrats and politicians at the state level can have a field day, receiving usual kickbacks. As for states like Gujarat, black market will flourish in seeds.
It should be clear foxes are set to feast out of the ubiquitous eggplant. Ignorant consumers with a crab mentality who cares little for the farmers’ interests will go on cheering the foxes for some period. But, eventually, technology can’t be held in ransom for long to satisfy fanatical activists and vested interests.
GEAC recommended to the government in October 2009, that Bt brinjal could be commercially released. Four months and several tumultuous, highly publicised consultation meetings later, Environment Minister Jairam Ramesh has announced a 'moratorium' on its 'commercial release'.
The ‘public consultations’ in seven cities were a gimmick to get some media publicity for Ramesh. Some 8000 activists – most of them city-bred socialites with absolutely no knowledge of agriculture or biotechnology – attended the meetings. The scenes they made were projected by the media as stiff resistance from farmers.
“The moratorium will last till such time independent scientific studies establish, to the satisfaction of both the public and professionals, the safety of the product from the point of view of its long-term impact on human health and environment, including the rich genetic wealth existing in brinjal in our country,” according to a release from his ministry.
The period would ostensibly be used to commission fresh scientific studies and reform the testing process. The minister said, “If you need long term toxicity tests, then you must do it, no matter how long it takes… There is no hurry. There is no overriding urgency or food security argument for Bt brinjal.” The government will apparently use the moratorium period to restore public confidence and trust in the Bt brinjal product. “If it can’t be done, so be it,” Ramesh said.
The minister who has already made his fortunes doesn’t realise that while there is no hurry for government-paid bureaucrats, the farmer is in a tearing hurry to reduce mounting cost of pesticides and risk of crop failure. The actual effect of the 'moratorium' will be only to give a breather to the pesticides lobby and to line certain officials’ pockets.
The fate of the ‘ban’ can be predicted from what happened to Bt cotton perfected by the same company based on a decade of intense research. It was ready for release by the turn of the century but it too became a victim of resistance from vested interests, albeit not so loud.
“The moratorium will last till such time independent scientific studies establish, to the satisfaction of both the public and professionals, the safety of the product from the point of view of its long-term impact on human health and environment, including the rich genetic wealth existing in brinjal in our country,” according to a release from his ministry.
The period would ostensibly be used to commission fresh scientific studies and reform the testing process. The minister said, “If you need long term toxicity tests, then you must do it, no matter how long it takes… There is no hurry. There is no overriding urgency or food security argument for Bt brinjal.” The government will apparently use the moratorium period to restore public confidence and trust in the Bt brinjal product. “If it can’t be done, so be it,” Ramesh said.
The minister who has already made his fortunes doesn’t realise that while there is no hurry for government-paid bureaucrats, the farmer is in a tearing hurry to reduce mounting cost of pesticides and risk of crop failure. The actual effect of the 'moratorium' will be only to give a breather to the pesticides lobby and to line certain officials’ pockets.
The fate of the ‘ban’ can be predicted from what happened to Bt cotton perfected by the same company based on a decade of intense research. It was ready for release by the turn of the century but it too became a victim of resistance from vested interests, albeit not so loud.
Although trials proved that cotton crop worth millions could be saved from the dreaded weevil infestation dependably even while drastically reducing pesticide costs, clearance was held up for four years. By the time the Central government formally released it, enterprising farmers, particularly in well-off states like Gujarat, had taken their own decision about cultivating the variety.
As happens in any market, bureaucratic prohibition on advanced technology was circumvented. The stakeholders can’t afford to wait indefinitely as it may take decades to address all safety issues. Even as the minions of GEAC threatened to burn their ‘illegal’ crop, a couple of successful crops were harvested. The farmers didn’t mind paying black-market rates for seeds because the savings in pesticides far exceeded the extra cost.
The pesticides lobby, whose survival is threatened while the farmer prospers by opting BT crops, understandably, has vested interest in delaying adoption. The other vested interests benefiting from the prohibition are black market traders of seeds. Eco-terrorists operating from posh offices and shuttling in air-conditioned cars derive wide publicity from their budgets, but the farmers know what is good for them.
Incidentally, Union ministers of environment, agriculture and science and technology and the Prime Minister's office have openly supported immediate release. Obviously, the company has already taken care of their concerns.
Just like almost 80 per cent of cotton from India today is under Bt variety, it can be safely predicted that the ‘moratorium’ can’t last long with regard to other crops. Possibly, farmers will stop cultivating fringe varieties of eggplants in three to four years.
Gujarat's share of aubergine production, currently around 12 per cent of India's consumption, may have tripled by the time the formal clearance comes. Till then, pesticide manufacturers will get a breather for survival in other states. Bureaucrats and politicians at the state level can have a field day, receiving usual kickbacks. As for states like Gujarat, black market will flourish in seeds.
It should be clear foxes are set to feast out of the ubiquitous eggplant. Ignorant consumers with a crab mentality who cares little for the farmers’ interests will go on cheering the foxes for some period. But, eventually, technology can’t be held in ransom for long to satisfy fanatical activists and vested interests.
 | Previous Post |
Login
 Login through Social ID
|
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.
