| Last updated less than one minute ago
Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
Follow Us
  
Does MBA mean 'Mentally Blocked Aadmi'!
The years in a B-school put a cage around the free creative mind of a young soul, teaching students to be good employees. In fact, most of the B schools are doing good business from the students rather then imparting real education.
THE ELEPHANT trainers, they say, tie baby elephant to a pole with a chain. The animal is kept tied till it becomes adult and then the chain is removed. But the elephant still does not go away because mentally it always feels itself tied to that pole. Somewhat same thing happens in the B-schools too. There are millions of students dying to get into B-schools to get an MBA degree and B schools too charge exorbitant fees to teach students various fundas and tricks of business.
 
I have studied in a good B-school myself and know it inside out. Simple things are expressed in mind boggling, impressive jargon and there are activities like corporate lectures to impress industry people. But what I have always noticed and felt is our esteemed faculties mould the young and inquisitive minds into a slave mentality. To any act of indiscipline on the part of students, the usual and the first reaction of the faculty is ‘this is not expected of you, how you will survive in a job?’ Or ‘such acts will not make any company recruit you people’ … I have been through all this, and I still wonder why don’t the faculty take it in a slightly different light and say ‘this is not expected of you, how will you manage your own venture this way?’
 
The years in a B-school puts a cage around the free creative mind of a young soul, teaching students to be good employees and to keep their bosses happy, to work like a machine, never to say no to any work, to defend their job with their life, etc but hardly if ever to be good entrepreneurs and to recruit and keep ‘their’ employees happy and satisfied. They teach us to generate new ideas to get early promotions but not to start a new venture of our own. Even the biggest B-school carries this mentality though, it’s now hanging fast. B-schools, agreed, teach us business but also make us perceive a job as a most precious thing.
 
Where are all the ethics gone? The B-grads learn to excel in jobs with chutzpah and to be competitive even with friends, and carry razor sharp professionalism in their attitude, a typical trait they have learnt in B-schools and are quite proud of, but what the MBA has not taught them is where to and with whom to apply this professionalism of theirs. That’s why half of them end up making rounds of mental counselors. None of the faculties (except that of the subject ‘entrepreneurship development’ that too is an elective one, carrying minor weight) ever encourages entrepreneurship.
 
Are we churning out manager-robots from our high profile B-schools, who are going to carry this mental attitude with a pride all their life? Just like the poor elephant that spends its entire life tied to a pole absolutely unaware of its strength, thanks to the mental block it has been put into!
Commenting System
COMMENTS (5)
.MBA's Really are Mentally Blocked Aadmi . Why do we Indians refer the Management Institutes as B-Schools ? Entrepreneurship is the most easiests in the world , and the most toughest thing too . It takes much toil and effort to be an entrepreneur but one must have the resilient power to withstand the failures , have enough patience , Passion is the prime motivator in being an entrepreneur . The mindset of an Entrepreneur and the mindset of an MBA are quite different . Even the Mindets of an Entrepreneur and the Mindset of an Employee are 180 degrees opposite . I Salute the Entrepreneurs !!!
.Very right ! Most of the B-Schools, or for that matter almost all professional schools are earning by churning out obedient robots to serve rather than encouraging innovative and free thinking.
1 Replies
hi thanks a lot for this wonderful comment :)
.very relevant points... good job..me too an mba student...n would like to share my recent experience of my marketing class(little drifted from topic though)...where the faculty of a subject like marketing which is very dynamic n practical... expects student to mugup Philip Kotler and use it as a base in group discussions and case studies presenation..if u think beyond it.....then u r wrong( becuse its not mentioned in kotler)...because kotler is marketing guru..through this medium i would like to say al those faculties who takes books as standards..should use these books as guiding lights to help us enter in dat particular domain, to wider our horizons..n start thinking process..rather than the ultimate thing...where there is no scope beyond that.
2 Replies
Mugging Up Phillip Kotler will lead you nowhere . Be an Entrepreneur and you may use it for reference in practical application then you will not only gain knowledge but will also get inspiration. Learning is a slow process and it takes time.
Hi Khushboo, Thanx for commenting and sharing your experience. Really, the students are expected most of the time to mug the written lines of standard textbooks, and anything out of them is considered wrong. The teachers forget that these standards were set only when someday someone thought out of the box !
.Well very correct thought .I feel the same and with International experience of 15 yrs in various profiles and industries I believe and preach that mental attitude is one of the prime barometers of success in my lectures on Personality Deevlopment to trainess of all ages Salim Shaikh { Architect - Build Business , Careers , Consulting } Bridging the gap between Academia & Industry Executive Director,Apple Inc. U.S.A Authorised Service & Sales Partners,Solution Experts Projects : - Training to Speakwell Academy etc. on Personality Dev.,Communication Skills etc.. - Business Consultancy to Firms of Different Levels - Citizen Journalism Cell - 0091 9892612474 Email-sallimsh@yahoo.com
1 Replies
Hi Mr. Salim, Thanks for the encouraging comment, particularly from a person of your experience and standing.
.accha hai, MBA has other meanings as well like MUJE BAHUT AATA HAI,should change this attitude and accept Real world ,at this time of economic slowdown.
1 Replies
Hi Vinod, Thanx a lot for commenting and also for a new, interesting meaning of MBA. Really hope the present slowdown will force people to change the attitude and to think innovatively.
Individual User Corporate User ( For submitting Press Release and Jobs )
Email / Login ID
Password