Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
Political Play
Zulfiqar Shah
Economic justice, line of wealth approach and development 10 March, 2019
The changes in the modern economy in the post twentieth century scientific advancements have changed the relations around the mode of production. This has caused an uneven economic development in the society and economy causing broader accumulation of wealth that results in enhanced gap between poor and rich, which even cannot be balanced or undone through re-distribution of the wealth by the existing economic systems in the countries.

In fact, the "Consumables" are essential human requirements for survival. Economic disparity has caused accumulation as well as control of consumption with the wealthy and powerful, meanwhile poor is struggling for his survival which essentially is an economic survival of the fittest.     

Economic Justice is basically four pronged: equal rights of all on the natural resources; public audit and payout on the wealth accumulation beyond certain limit; equality amongst all haves and have-nots both; and post scientific revolution equal economic opportunities for all.  In the absences of economic justice, slavery, unemployment, crime and violence cannot end. Economic justice is when freedom and equality in terms of economy are given to all that in turn will strengthen the freedom and equality in other spheres of life.

Majority in the world is wealthless. "In order to establish justice, all aspects of socio-political economy need to be rethought. Justice is all citizens have equal rights on natural resources in a country. Human persons have this right since the birth." In a bid to establish economic justice, an approach change is required. World has to withdraw the much touted approach of Line of Poverty. Instead, it requires the approach Line of Wealth. Line of Wealth is simply putting a ceiling on the per capita possession of wealth that should be declared one's fundamental right and go untaxed.

The wealth, more than the ceiling of wealth possession, should heavily be taxed; meanwhile all other forms domestic taxes should be abolished. Thereafter, the revenues generated due to wealth tax, which the author has termed scholar and economist Roshan Lal Agrawal terms 'national income' in his book Line of Wealth should be utilized for the government requirement, while the remaining revenues or net saving after government expenditures should equally be distributed among the citizens. "An ideal economy is when all means of production together meet the needs of people."

The new taxation regime of one-tax system levied on the wealth exceeding the ceiling called Line of Wealth will generate extraordinarily more revenues than the existing revenue generation of the countries is. 

The natural resources today are scarce for the next generation. A fundamental purpose of the economy is to provide consumables in abundances to meet consumption requirement and avert scarcity of consumable ? in a bid to avoid scarcity, human has developed science, art, structure and process of economy. "Consumption" causes accumulation of wealth which in turn results into social-disorder. Besides, due to non-existence of economic justice the vested interest of the wealthy globally has started interfering in the electoral sovereignty of various countries. 

It is also essential that a family needs to be registered with the government, and is also required to consensually select a representative for engaging with the government.

Human labor should also be included as a major price determining factor. Besides, the market malpractices should undergo the check and balance along with educating consumers, traders and producers. The over production of commodities or consumables is mostly discarded by the producer to maintain the price of the commodity in the market, which is an inhuman and anti-nature practice. This causes environmental hazards. Why not such surplus production be given to the poorest in the world?

If analyzed, the classical setting of capitalism versus socialism, the capitalism gives freedom of vote and expression, while socialism access to the consumables to all; however, it does not offer political and individual liberties and freedoms including right to free vote. Similarly, capitalism does not offer total democracy i.e. equality and freedom in the economy.

Taxation in India like many other countries in the world is inappropriate. It favors the wealthy besides causing tax theft through institutional, legal and procedural loop-holes. Only one-tax system is the way forward for a taxation having human face and justice.

Most of the investors in the world seek loan from the banks, produce commodities and offer services through business based on the loans. They include the interest on the loan in the price of the commodities and service hence consumers pay their loans. Therefore, interest on the loan should be collective and be divided among the all stakeholders.

The unavoidable truth of the human history is everyone in the country has unalienable natural right on the natural resources.

This, the vision of economic justice, will ultimately cause minimal government and maximum governance. This is the only way forward for the south Asian economies, the economies of underdeveloped world as well as a niche for the developed countries.

This vision is by economist and scholar Roshan Lal Agrawal, the founder of Economic Justice Foundation. The vision is extensively expressed in his Hindi book, "Amiri Rekha Nahi, Gharibi Rekha". The English version of the book, "Line of Wealth" soon will be released for the readers. The books will be available with the book stores in India, res of the Southasia and other countries of the world. The online print copy as well e-book and Kindle version will soon be available on Amazon, Flipkart, INGRAM and other online outlets, and the book stores in the various countries of the world. 

The author is activist, analyst and economist. Twitter: @shahzulf

Editorial NOTE: This article is categorized under Opinion Section. The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of In case you have a opposing view, please click here to share the same in the comments section.
About The Author
Zulfiqar Shah is a stateless activist, analyst, and researcher. Although he is a refugee, and living a life in exile, he is a born Sindhi and South Asian. Currently he lives in India.
Email Id
Verification Code
Email me on reply to my comment
Email me when other CJs comment on this article
Sign in to set your preference
merinews for RTI activists

Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.