Singing of Vande Mataram in any form should be prohib ited. It is not as per constitution. It is merely a song. Not much importance is attached. All Muslims must condemn this. This is anti Muslim. Shapath should also be taken in Urdu and not Hindi

its right that we shoud ban vande mataram nad it is also right that its national song there is only solution that we should ban muslim or we should change lines in vande mataram its written like we should pray for our mother

Vande Matram contains some lines which declare the soil of motherland a deity. This is against basic tenets of Islam. Even worshipping one's mother or Prophet is not allowed for Muslims. Hence,demanding Muslims to sing it is, in fact, demanding them to convert to non-Islam, which is a very dangerous demand. Not singing Vande Matram does not mean not loving the motherland in the same manner as Muslims do not worship their actual mothers and their Prophet but they love them.Muslims have always proved their patriotism and sacrificed their lives in thousands for the country. Expression of love for one's motherland does not lie only in singing it. There are many ways to express it. Can we say that Chattopadhyay remained unpatriotic to the country before his composition of this poem in 1875? Can we say that all nationalists before 1875 were unpatriotic because they never sang it? Can Muslims be justified in demanding all Indians to be buried in the soil of the motherland in spite of being burnt after death? The answer is NO.Then why are they being demanded to sing it while it is they who composed the famous song "Sare Jahan Se Achcha …"and sing it