Welcome Guest, Login    IPL 2010
 Home |  World | India | Sports | Business | Technology | Entertainment | Lifestyle | Potpourri | Reviews | Press Releases | Interviews | Citizen Journalism
Home > India > Article
Noida rape: A clash of cultures
New Delhi is one city that keeps witnessing a clash of two extreme cultures. One is emerging urban, the other is the rural surrounding Delhi. The neo rich farmers who have sold land at astronomical prices lack education, hence the clash
 
Sat, Jan 10, 2009 18:37:30 IST
Views:
3631
   Comments:
10
Rate:  1 out of 5 2 out of 5 3 out of 5 4 out of 5 5 out of 5 4.91 / 108 votes

THE RECENT incidents of violence in the National Capital Region (NCR) have once again shaken the capital. The Nithari incident, Arushi murder case and now the henious gang rape. Sporadic group clashes have become ordinary incidents. The gang rape of an MBA student has made everyone insecure. The casual approach of the crime makes one think that it can happen to anyone at anytime.

The series of such crimes in the NCR is a result of a cultural clash. Nowhere else in the country, is there such a close juxtaposition of two extreme cultures. Delhi, though peopled mostly by outsiders has a culture. A metropolitan culture, men and women equally enjoy their share in the society. Girls go to schools, colleges and workplaces as freely as the boys. They also share their freedom equally. Boys and girls can walk, go to markets, films and even to the parks to spend some intimate moments. These are all that have become an accepted norm of metros. Delhi is the hub of international events and fashion shows. A good number of foreign visitors walk freely on the streets of the capital. Besides, being a political centre, Delhi is also a centre of education. All these, have contributed to the expansion of the city. Delhi is all set to become a world class city.

Inspite of all this, Delhi is also one of the cities that keep witnessing a clash of two extreme cultures. One is emerging urban, the other is rural. The outskirts of Delhi are peopled by farmers. Their primary source of income is cultivation. Close to India’s capital, they have acres of lands. Ironically, the emerging urban middle class in Delhi is struggling hard to own at least a two bedroom flat. As Delhi is expanding, these land owners found their barren land as jackpots. Suddenly they became rich, they have all the facilities that a rich has. What they still lack is education. The villages around Delhi are unique in nature. They are rural only in terms of their lifestyle, they have all the facilities that a city has. They have rather more facilities than many cities of India. It’s good, in fact very good. But their abundance of infrastructure in lack of education, at times invades to entity of their co-inhabitants.

The Noida incident of gang rape is the rape of a new emerging middle class by the well off  but boorish, ignorant and uncivilised neighbours of the Indian capital. This is not the first incident. The murder of Jessica Lal was an act of the same fraternity. Lack of education and abundance of money has made these urchins think that they can do whatever they can. The incident makes one think of how pathetic the conditions would be of girls in their villages. These incidents are hurdles for an emerging India.

The rapists must be punished severely. At the same time the situation needs to be seen in a broader perspective. The co existence of rural and urban cultures will further witness such incident if proper measures are not taken.

 E-mail | Print | Post comment
 
Post your comment
Post
Posted comments (11)
 
Comments
 
 
|
Reply to Comment | New Comment | Report Abuse
 
 
 
Oh so you want a personal fight? So be it! So you are saying that the Satyam financial scandal is petty thievery????Yes, you can get a lot of men who would pounce on other men when they speak up because men are yet to be liberated! Yes, you can always cry loud that a guy called rohan needs to be taken care of and a million of those men would be competing with each other to please you just in the hope that they could get sexual favours from you. This is nature's way. Can't help. If you were not a man-hater, you wouldn't be saying such wicked things. But yes you are a man-hater and want men to be subservient to women. For that, you keep showing the carrot of sex which men are always after. How decent are you when you say all men will pay for the crimes of a few? What decency do you have or deserve? Yes, I am also going to get highly personal at you.....HELL.....do you have a problem with your eyes? I have clearly stated THAT MY ARGUMENTS ARE NOT AND NEVER A DEFENCE TO THE CRIME THAT THE BOYS HAVE DONE....THEY DESERVE THE PUNISHMENT. I HAVE CLEARLY REBUTTED YOUR THEORY OF RAPE........get your eyes tested! Marriage and sex has become very difficult because OF FEMINAZIS LIKE YOU WHO HAVE PASSED ANTI-MALE LAWS TO LOOT MEN OF THEIR PROPERTY, ALIMONY, SALARY ETC..........HELL... ....FEMINISTS LIKE YOU WHO WANT ALL MEN TO BE LIKJE SLAVES FOR THE CRIMES OF A FEW AND ALL HUSBANDS TO BE SLAVES OF THEIR WIVES, FEMINISTS LIKE MADHURI WHO WANT MEN TO SUFFER......HOW CAN YOU BE A NEUTRAL PERSON? YOU ARE NOT. DO YOU EVEN KNOW WHAT HUMANITY AND CONSCIENCE IS ABOUT? LAW HAS TO BE EQUAL FOR ALL. IT CANNOT BE ON THE TERMS OF A FEW FEMINISTS.
 
 
|
Reply to Comment | New Comment | Report Abuse
 
 
Hey Rohan,man do not put everything platform..cheat is very different from asaulting someone physically... Femenism doesn't mean that someone is against men..and if you are talking about civilizations and culture then let me remind me that women are the starters of these civilizatins and culture.there is a woman who bore you for nine months in her womb and took care for several years and must be now also...how do know to respect her, must be in your family..so similarly a person understand everything by getting a proper education..
|
 
Madhuri, You are getting personal with me. Do you want me to get personal with you too??? I can if you want to. I am not here to waste my time. I object to your statement that all men will have to pay for this. Nonsense! Feminazism needs to be nipped in the bud just as Talibanism. How could you make such an atrocious statement? Would you say that your father, brothers and sons should be castrated for this crime? [Now castration is being demanded of rapists]. Secondly, the theory that rape is not about sexual arousal is absurd, and nonsensical!!! If rape is not about sexual arousal, and only about control, then they could have murdered or tortured them. Why a sexual assault???? Psychology is not gravely misplaced if according to you, it says so. Further, women also sexually assault men. Do you apply the same control and power theory to such cases??? Moreover, getting a girl friend, or married is not as simple and easy as you claim it to be. Not everybody can get things at will. [I am not referring to this incident; I am speaking in general]. Further, watching porn or masturbation is different from indulging in a sexual act with a woman. There is a lot of difference. Otherwise, people would not have had girl friends/ BFs or would not have got married. They could have permanently resorted to masturbation and watching porn. LASTLY, MEN WILL GIVE BACK FOR THIS ONE-SIDED PROPOGANDA OF MISANDRY AND MALE-HATREDNESS AS YOU YOURSELF HAVE SAID, "MEN WILL HAVE TO PAY FOR THIS". TWO WRONGS NEVER MAKE A RIGHT. IT CREATES ANOTHER WRONG. AS SIMPLE AS THAT!
 
 
|
Reply to Comment | New Comment | Report Abuse
 
 
Another point. The arguements are NOT and NEVER a justification for the crime. It is only intended to get a clearer picture and also to ensure that these incidents are not taken as an excuse to spread misandry and androphobia in society. A few men are bad; few women are bad too. When women commit crimes, the society doesn't sit up and take it so seriously. Lastly, my responses are also aimed at giving an overall perspective as against the narrow perspective. Everybody needs to be responsible for the freedom that he/ she gets.
|
Ok Rohan, I get your point, and yes, it IS personal. Let me also say that if your sister or mom or grandmom is raped, I will be waiting eagerly for you to compare it to embezzlement and petty thieveryI am not a man hater, I can produce 10 men who will come here and say exactly the same thing, but I wont as your forum does not deserve my or any decent human being's time. I can see you haven't rebutted any of my major points on punishing criminals or the meaning of rapeIf marriage and sex is difficult, it is because of narrow-minded people like you who have made it so, and vermin like the 11 who raped a woman who dared make love outside the shroud of secrecy and shame, YES, its personal!You clearly have a vested interest in this forum and in inciting argument, I wish you joy in your life choice, and also in your complete lack of conscience or humanity. Jai Hind dude!
|
IPL 2010
Latest in India