Khelein Hum Jee Jaan Sey, another film on the same theme of Chittagong Armoury Raid is a Hindi period piece film based on the book 'Do And Die' by Manini Chatterjee, directed by Ashutosh Gowariker, which gets the patronage of the Big B for its release. Pain did not depend on one particular book. He studied varied sources and talked to many people and in a word, the film is the outcome of a long academic research. He made Jhunku and not Masterda to play the lead role. Mulk Raj Anand introduced the character of Mahatma Gandhi but Raja Rao in his Kanthapura did not do it. This is also true of Pain’s film. Jhunku is here the alter ego of Masterda who himself was inspired by his teacher to join the freedom movement.
Masterda Surya Sen (played by Manoj Bajpai in the film) dared to take on the empire with a group of schoolboys and young women and a few colleagues. But this story was secondary and multiple perspectives enrich the plot. The diffident 14-year-old boy, Jhunku coming under the spell of Masterda seems to be more important in the film. Chittagong has a psychological base and the story of Surya Sen Masterda is in the distant background more as a myth for the young boy. It is a vague myth reflecting the aspirations of the youth who are maddened by the desire for freedom like Moorthy of Raja Rao’s Kanthapura.
The name of Masterda iconises fight against the British Raj. Surya Sen was initiated into the revolutionary world in 1916 by one of his teachers while he was an arts student at the Behrampore College. On his return to Chittagong in 1918, he became the President of the Indian National Congress. He revived the hardline patriotic organization including Jugantar in different parts of the Chittagong district. He was convinced of the need for secret guerilla warfare against the colonial government. There are beautiful scenic shots showing the broad day robbery at the treasury office of the Assam –Bengal Railway at Chittagong.
Pain also elaborately portrayed the rather vague historical incident to focus on the success rather than the defeat in the Armoury Raid of 1930. It was the first anti -British revolutionary violence and the camera had its distinct focus on it. The 1930 Chittagong Uprising was among the first events to challenge colonial authority, setting the stage for India’s independence in 1947. Master Da was one such character. He dared to dream that the mighty British Empire can be defeated militarily. All these are chronicled in the film Chittagong and people will enjoy them both in Bangladesh and India.
Persuasive period details and competent filmmaking are not enough to overcome the predominantly self-conscious writing and unimpressive performances either, rendering the film more passing curiosity than epic milestone. Many history books depict the Chittagong uprising as finished when Master Da gets killed but 90% of the people who took part in Chittagong struggle actually survived and participated in many more struggles later. Master Da's character was one of the most difficult characters to portray chiefly because his character is inspiring like that of Subhash Bose, another real person whose life is shrouded in mystery. Everybody in Bengal knows about Master Da, and Pain very rightly as a director chose to show a positive aspect in the film on the Chittagong uprising.
He does not leave the audience unsatisfied with the sense of a glorious defeat. The film’s essentially anecdotal material and youthful point of view, however, cannot generate sufficient excitement or gravitas to fashion either an all-out action-adventure or a sweeping epic. The most interesting part is played by Surya Sen’s alter ego Jhunku, the teenager boy who is running clandestine errands and undergoing training with the rebels’ few functional rifles. The victory is short lived because of the lack of military experience and a shortage of arms. It is by sheer courage that the group raids the local British garrison, sending the troops packing. The quick arrival of reinforcements make the insurrectionists totally at a disarray. They found confronting forces far beyond their expectations. Faced with seemingly insurmountable odds, Jhunku must make a choice between his commitment to liberty and surrendering to British authorities. Herein lies the topicality of the film and also its success.
The Bengali director of the film, Pain was in IIT Kharagpur, and was one of those 'good students'. Later he went to Columbia University for his Ph.D. He had been a senior research scientist at NASA and was one of the inventors of the active pixel sensor technology that produced the world's smallest camera. The basic digital camera technique is used in mobiles today. He has been inducted to the US Space Technology Hall of Fame. Later he worked with NASA for 18 years. The former NASA employee wrote 36 drafts of his film 'Chittagong' before taking the first shot. He demonstrates a flair and passion for filmmaking. He managed to read writings by various participants of Jalalabad battle like Suresh De. Chittagong is pivotal to Bangladesh as it is to India.
Most of the historical films end in a defeat. Take 'Mangal Pandey - The Rising' or 'The Legend of Bhagat Singh' for example. As in Rajkumar Santoshi's film, there is the sense of defeat when Bhagat Singh gets hanged. But in Pain’s film, the audience is left with a sense of victory. According to Pain, Masterda achieves an amazing triumph which is sometimes not even recognised because Chittagong uprising in my opinion didn't even end in 1934. What is more important about Pain’s film, is that it is a celebration of present not history.
'Chittagong' is very topical; it will remind you of what's happening today. While many associations surrounding India’s liberation from Britain center on Gandhi and the nonviolent independence movement, in fact it was a long series of political and social developments that eventually expelled the English. Pain focuses on the true story of the life of a revolutionary and at the same time hinted at the long process that continued even after Masterda’s courageous fight. The film beautifully focuses on this aspect. It is unfortunate that the release of the film was delayed because of Ashutosh Gowariker's Khelein Hum Jee Jaan Sey, starring Abhishek Bachchan and Deepika Padukone in the lead roles. Anurag Kasyap accusd Big B of delaying the release of the film. The producers, Anurag Kashyap and Sunil Bohra are even toying with the idea of releasing it on August 15 in India although it was ready for release on August 10. The film will feature music by trio Shankar Ehsaan Loy and Resul Pokutty will do the sound.
Barry John is impressive as Wilkinson. Vega Tamotia played the role of Pritilata Waddedar. Besides there is Nawazuddin Siddiqui to play the role of Nirmal Sen, Raj Kumar Yadav as Lokenath Bal, Jaideep Ahlwat as Anant Singh, Dibyendu Bhattacharya as Ambika, Vishal Vijay as Ganesh Ghosh and Alexx O’Nell as Charles Johnson, all of whom make the character cast vivid and effective. Dialogues written by Piyush Mishra are attractive and marked by dramatic intensity. In this kind of film the role of the costume designer is very important and Neelanjana Ghose did her job very well.