Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
Prime Minister's Speech - Issues in the RSS Penumbra
As expected, the Prime Minister found no words to condemn the Chauvinism and religious fanaticism. Several issues were raised without the proper sequence of importance as it was not a written script. The speech sounded more like an election diatribe that was hopping from one topic to other often with references that were detrop like Nepal's historical contribution.

He found nothing worth mentioning about most loved PM's Nehruji and Indraji. While describing the 'Heritage' or Virasat, he didn't found it fair and fit to include the wise king Akbar, the last Great Mughal Emperor-Freedom Fighter Bhahdur Shah Zafar or Shaheed Ashfaq Ullah Khan and Moulana Abul Kalam Azad. He forgot or deliberately ignored the multilayered diversity of Amir Khusro persona and talked of Yoga Guru Religious Philosopher Sri Arubindo and Swami Vivekananda only. Yes, Shastriji was found worth mentioning as he has handed over, in 1965 during Indo-Pak war, the policing of Delhi temporarily to RSS.

Rising prices was a non-issue.

PM had nothing to say about corruption! Strange, that was the plank that pushed the Congress into oblivion. Indirectly, everything about RSS ideology was spawned from the Red Ford except the Strong Message to condemn the riots. It was discussed casually like so many other topics of humdrum politics.

The Planning Commission ultimate demise was on cards but the sagacious PM didn't give a solid blue-print of what would and could replace it while its burial date are near. One wonders about the roles of Ambanis and Adnanis in the next derivative planning out-fit.

The glimpses of 'Ek Neeti Ek Vichar........" reminded the TIMES of EMERGENCY when nation was asked to follow the slogans of similar nature.

For the largest minority of India, nothing worth to talk about ! For the first time since India's Independence in 1947, there is no palpable Muslim representation in the majority party. Of the 283 Bhartiya Janata Party members elected to India's new Parliament, there's not a single Muslim representative. The lack of representation, combined with Mr. Modi's image as a hardliner Hindu politician, has caused fear and concern in the Muslim community. You talk to any informed Muslim and he feels a sort of ostracized from the main stream. Never before a whole community felt so isolated and frightened.

Following is the gist of reports gathered from confirmed reports at different times by different organizations:

It is a well-known fact that since independence, the Indian Muslims are being systematically and increasingly marginalized in the affairs of their own homeland. Soon after the independence, various states and territories were reorganized splitting the minority dominated areas in parts and absorbing them in different states with a view to reducing their influence and making it difficult for them to win in any election. 

In Jammu and Kashmir is the only state where Muslims are in majority. India is a vocal advocate of secularism but nowhere else in the world secularism was so blatantly betrayed. It was expected that in an independent India, Hindu fanaticism will completely evaporate. Long before independence, Moulana Azad had said, "I firmly hold that it (communal frenzy) will disappear when India assumes the responsibility of her own destiny."

In so-called secular India, Azad's hope was not only belied but Hindu fanaticism gained enormous strength and that also under the direct patronage of the government. The Congress party, which ruled India for over six decades, instead of making any effort to contain Hindu fundamentalism, did everything for its nourishment. Just after becoming the first President of independent India, Dr. Rajendra Prasad removed from the Rashtrapati Bhavan (President's House) all the Muslims who were working there. There are thousands of examples which show how secularism is being betrayed in India. Secularism was betrayed by the federal State government by covertly becoming a party to the demolition of the Babari Masjid.

The socio-economic conditions of the Muslim community of India present a dismal picture. The Muslims are deprived of due representation in public employment even at the lowest level. The representation of the Muslims in various Ministries is approaching to zero. Muslims are also failing to avail the equal opportunity in the private sector. The literacy level of the Muslim community is much below the average level of India. The school enrolment level of the Muslim children is also very low. Because of the hurdles at the lower level of education, the share of Muslim students at higher and professional level is also much below the national level of India.

In 'secular' India, schools and other educational institutions are being systematically saffronized with Hindu culture incorporating glorification of Hindu mythological characters. Collective singing of Vande Matram of Bankim Chaterjee is almost an established tradition. Urdu is the language of about 62 per cent of the Indian Muslims and has the richest Islamic literature among Indian languages in all fields of learning. As a part of their efforts to obliterate the cultural entity of the Muslims, both the Central Government and the Governments of the States seem to do whatever is possible to strangle this language and deny it all opportunities of existence and growth. It is virtually banished from all the schools run by the Government.

There are symptoms that space of Free Speech is shrinking in the democracy of Nehru and Gandhi. Not long ago, the famous book 'The Hindus: An Alternative History' by the academic Wendy Doniger was declared offensive towards their religion by a small hardline Hindu group and , forcing the mighty conglomerate publisher 'Penguin' were forced withdraw and pulp the book. In the aftermath of this episode two authors asked the publisher to cancel contracts and pulp their books, a move called "unprecedented" by one Indian newspaper. In the same period, a mob calling itself the Hindu Sena, burnt copies of Caravan, the Delhi-based magazine, over an interview with a Hindu extremist.

The famous brave writer activist Arundhati Roy, an intellectual with a conscience, declared the withdrawl of the book as an act of succumbing to "fascists" forces. Liberals in India feel under strain and than ever before about the right to expression as religious groups increasingly are flexing their muscles. Many fear that Hindu Fundamentalists are further emboldened as Modi, their most demagogic leader is elected prime minister.

Hindu fundamentalism has been given a new name ? Hindutva. Their concept of  "Hindu nationalism is built on the idea that India is a Hindu majoritarian nation, with Muslims and Christians cast as the minority, 'other'." RSS' Hindutva says that India should be an exclusive Hindu nation state.

Today, Narndra Modi is the elected Prime Minister of India and he is a firm believer in RSS ideology. He did never hide his commitment to RSS ideology. A large part of Modi's popularity comes from his message that Gujarat can be a beacon for India's economic development. He talked tirelessly about his Gujarati pride. I don't know how to recall my Muslim Pride.

So, while we celebrate the Independence Day with gusto in company of our countrymen, we have a lot of reason to feel estranged in our own house.

Editorial NOTE: This article is categorized under Opinion Section. The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of In case you have a opposing view, please click here to share the same in the comments section.
Email Id
Verification Code
Email me on reply to my comment
Email me when other CJs comment on this article
Sign in to set your preference
Shaista Qezalbash
Mohan Bhagwat, the RSS chief, on Sunday asked if inhabitants of England are English, Germany are Germans and USA are Americans then why all inhabitants of Hindustan are not known as Hindus. “The cultural identity of all Indians is Hindutva and the present inhabitants of the country are descendants of this great culture,” Bhagwat said while speaking at the ‘Golden Jubilee’ function of an Odia weekly in Bhubaneswar. Perhaps he is unaware of the fact that very word ‘Hindu’ was coined by Muslim Warriors who came from Central Asia. He received flak from non-BJP parties for his suggestion that all Hindustanis are Hindus with many leaders wondering if he has read the Constitution and really believes in it. Congress leader Manish Tewari said Bhagwat would be well-advised to read the Constitution which very specifically states that India is Bharat, a union of state, and the word “Hindustan” is nowhere mentioned. Sitaram Yechury of CPI(M) said Bhagwat should make it clear if he believes in Constitution. “He should make it clear if he believes in it. In our Constitution, the country is Bharat not Hindustan,” he told reporters. JD(U) President Sharad Yadav said India has come so far since Independence by keeping its faith in the Constitution and its future lies in following the same course. BSP Chief and former Uttar Pradesh Chief Minister Mayawati while slamming Bhagwat said he does not have “proper knowledge” of the Constitution. “When Ambedkar ji (Bhimrao Ambedkar) wrote the Constitution he kept in mind that our country comprises various religions and people follow them. So the name Bharat was given, the word Hindustan was not used. The RSS chief does not have proper knowledge of the Constitution. He should learn that and then comment,” she said. Father Savrimuthu of Archdiocese of Delhi expressed concern over Bhagwat’s comments, saying India is a pluralistic country but the RSS head has tried to put everybody under one umbrella. “Our nation is great and known for unity and diversity… Now you (RSS) are trying to make one nation, one religion, one culture, trying to put everybody under one umbrella which is not right.” It is high time that Narendra Modi should break his Moun Varat on this topic and tell the nation where he stands.
merinews for RTI activists

Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.