Case reminds of infamous Jessica Lal murder case when the case was re-opened after severe criticism from media and civil society. It is something different that the criticised judge got an instant side-by-side promotion as a high court judge. Ruchika Girotra case should also be re-opened to ensure severe-most punishment to the guilty apart from an open enquiry by a commission of enquiry to probe into allegations of undue favour for SPS Rathore either during his professional career or during court-proceedings.