Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
  
Should the age of consent to have sex be lowered?
A can of worms has been opened by the government by proposing lowering the age of consent to sex from present 18 years to 16 years in a new criminal (amendment) bill, which will replace the February 3 ordinance on rape laws. Women and child development ministry is not happy with the new bill and would likely veto the bill on the ground that it is in variance with the Protection of Children from Sexual Offenses Act, 2012 - passed by the Parliament in May last year - which had fixed the age of consent for sex at 18 years.

While the people higher up in the ministry are crying foul on the matter, people in general think that not much will change with the bill. Many people didn’t even know that there existed an age bar on sex. And one person, who wished to be anonymous, said that till he read the news in the morning newspaper he was not aware that such a bar existed in India.

Poll
Do you support Govt's decision to lower the age of consent for sex?
Yes :
28.57 %
No :
71.43 %
Can't say :
0 %
Sponsored By :
That might be taking the matters to an extreme end, but Sheba Imam, founder of Lets Walk Gurgaon said, “In a healthy situation, where two people are of almost the same age, both are consenting and there is no dis-balance in the power equation, lowering the age group is not harmful. The Judiciary or the authorities responsible should decode the power equation so that coercion doesn't happen at any time.” This is the trickiest part and the angle that the authorities should take into consideration before making any decision.

Even if the age is lowered, it doesn't answer a big question: 'Are Indian children mature enough at the age of 16 years to get involved in physical intimacy?' Two kinds of answers came to the forefront. Richa Dubey of Gurgaon Girlcott said, “Given the time that we are living in, yes children become mature by 16. If we compare them with my generation then today kids are much more advanced - physically, mentally, and sexually.”

Contradicting this opinion, Sumedha Goswami, who works as a PR person in a prestigious firm said, “I don't think that 16 years is a good enough age to commit to any physical relationship, as at that age teenagers are vulnerable, naive and not mature enough to make such decisions. We might have advanced in many ways but even now people in India are not that mature by 16 years.”

Assuming that the bill is passed and the age of consent to have sex is lowered from 18 to 16 years, so will it have any effect on the masses? Sudipta Sengupta, senior management person said, “The age bar actually does not make a difference as people will do what they have to do. Kids these days are mature enough, although this differs from person to person. But I feel a whole lot will not change (if age is lowered).”

The bill would, however, complicate matters as chances of abuse of teenagers will increase. The authorities, with this bill, are actually creating more loopholes for criminals to escape, and they should think it through before making any hasty decision. If the age of consent was set at 18 years, then it was done for a reason. Agreed that with urbanization kids are growing up faster but the scenario is not the same for all over India as we still have rural areas where a lot of abuse takes place, and this bill will only increase the evil.

COMMENTS (5)
Guest
Name
Email Id
Verification Code
ankur
This is not the real issue. Media and women organizations have discovered artificial issue to discuss so that real issues are not discussed and unconstitutional laws can be passed without any dispute. Real issue is that men accused of rape will be put behind bars and they have to prove that they are innocent. This tells that there are no human rights for men. Other laws that can be misused are related to voyeurism and stalking. Where it is easy to make false accusations on anybody and again men have to prove innocence. There is no law to punish women who wear revealing/provocative dresses. There is no protection for men who get routinely raped in prisons. This country is for women and job of men is to provide privileges to women.
Kamal Shah
First their should be a national policy on education of SEX ....traditional values v/s western culture...Why we adopt the worst of the west and explore it to exploit it later.
nothing can be more shameful...
gautam roy
IT IS A SHAMEFUL ACT. In age of 16 a girl/boy is not matured enough atleast by mind to act and thing of future at same time. This will encourage prostitution in school going girls for greed of money and luxorious life. Same time will enourage Rape cases as the super rich will have a fresh young girl daily and the poor school boys may land to jail if pail to make full payment to any of them. Age for sex without marriage with family concent should be atleast 25 years when they will be a little mature to think of their future.
Anand Krishnan
If Govt really serious then definitely the age of consent to have sex to be lowered and to tackle such ongoing Heinous Crime, Capital Punishment/ Shoot at site order must by law at earliest if found guilty then only such heinous On going can be tackled other wise another Women/ Girl/ minors will have to become sufferer ?
merinews for RTI activists

Create email alerts

Total subscribers: 205583
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.