Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
  
Unjust Humanity
Virag
The devastating psychological impacts of false allegations on men 04 February, 2014
"False allegations of abuse, are abuse", read a placard at one of the street protests organized by an organization working to create awareness about victimized and distressed men.

The message was prominent, when a man is falsely accused of an allegation of torture and harassment by a woman, the society takes the abuse of the man therein very lightly and expects the man to downplay the whole incident without realizing that accusing a man falsely is a very serious form of abuse on the man.

Of late, there has been quite a lot of brouhaha about false dowry cases, false rape cases, false sexual harassment cases being filed against innocent men who are sent behind bars without trial or investigation. However, not many people know about the seriousness of these false cases and what does an innocent man go through in the process.

Various organizations have mushroomed across the geographies of India who are working to support victimized and distressed men and the contacts of the organizations are abuzz with stories of innocent men being victimized under false cases, false allegations. Years of research in studying the underlying pattern behind these false cases unearths interesting psychological revelations about how society (including men) treats men.

To begin with, the story does not end at filing a false case or leveling a false allegation. It’s the beginning. The real abuse of the man starts when these false allegations are taken at face value, and no attempt is made to verify the tenacity of the allegations, rather, using the false allegations as an excuse, the man is abused further and such abuse of men is acceptable socially.

Not only that, many innocent have been punished, beaten up, severely demeaned, merely on the basis of assumptions and allegations and are also made to compensate to the woman who levels false allegations because after all she is a woman whom the society considers as holy saints who never lie while all men are born criminals.

Some instances of abuse of men under false allegations are,

1. Even, if the case is false, the man is still forced to take a bail without any investigation, merely on the basis of complaint and if it is a complaint of rape/dowry death, he is jailed for months together before even being granted bail and there is no respite available for the man.

2. In maintenance cases, merit is rarely looked at, by the courts and even if the woman is capable of maintaining herself, courts grant maintenance as the woman has complained of neglect and desertion.

3. Often courts order huge amounts to be paid to the woman while granting bail orders to men trapped in false dowry cases.

4. Men have to keep on fighting cases containing baseless allegations as courts, society refuse to provide relief to such men and also refuse to punish such abusive women who trap innocent men in false cases for their selfish gains.

5. Men implicated in false cases live a life of criminal even though they have not committed any crime.

Above abuse of men is just the tip of the iceberg and a single article cannot encapsulate or articulate the immense emotional turmoil that men go through when they are trapped in false cases containing false, baseless and frivolous allegations.

However, it is pertinent to highlight some of the devastating psychological impacts that happen on men when false allegations are leveled on the man and he is put to task for the same.

Loss of self-esteem: Men start developing guilt feelings when a woman levels false allegations on a man and the society constantly hammers him with the same. As a result he starts developing very low self-esteem and this degrades his overall quality of life.

Low on confidence: When men are abused merely because a woman has filed some allegations against him (whether true or false) and despite attempts by the man to prove his innocence, he is considered as a criminal, many men lose their confidence and even become paranoid.

Developing mistrust: When, falsely accused, and there is no justice done to the innocent man and he is abused as well, he loses trust on the society, law and order system and people in general. This is a very unhealthy sign socially and if the numbers of rising false cases aren’t arrested, very soon we would have a society of individuals with high amount of mistrust amongst each other.

Fear of relationships: Men develop psychological phobia towards developing relationships once falsely accused. Not only that, other men, close to the man falsely accused, also, at times, develop psychological phobia towards developing relationships.

Hatred of women: For all the torture that women do on men, still hatred is an unhealthy psychological condition and must not be harbored. However, when men are abused by women followed by false allegations that are leveled on the men and ends of justice aren’t met; many men develop feelings of deep hatred towards women.

Fear Psychosis: Men develop a lot of fears about various aspects of life as they are tortured, abused and terrorized with false allegations.

These devastating psychological impacts on falsely accused men, is currently not a concern for the society and we do not have any kind of redress mechanism to save innocent men from false cases and this reality is a big concern for men. It’s time the Government takes curative steps in the direction of stopping false cases against men.


Editorial NOTE: This article is categorized under Opinion Section. The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of merinews.com. In case you have a opposing view, please click here to share the same in the comments section.
About The Author
Virag R Dhulia, a software professional, has been a prominent men's rights activist. He has been engaged in creating awareness about the abuse of men and their families through anti-male and gender biased laws like Section 498A, Domestic Violence Act etc. He has been instrumental in networking with fellow men's rights activist both across India and abroad and has played key roles in organizing events to create awareness about abuse of men by the society. A book titled, 'The Secrets of Manhood' authored by Virag has been published. This book is a collection of short articles which focus on issues and problems faced by men and how men are victims of social stereotypes.
COMMENTS (9)
Guest
Name
Email Id
Verification Code
Email me on reply to my comment
Email me when other CJs comment on this article
}
Sign in to set your preference
Excellent writeup by Virag that truely depicts the plight of falsely Accused man and brings to fore the rising snowballing trend of implicating men using heavy gender biased laws. The Misuse and abuse of these Draconian laws by Women and then going scot free is destroying the delicate inter gender trust. Delhi's Dwarka special fast track court hearing RAPE cases has made recommendations to government to make provisions in Crpc to enable the court to direct either State or the prosecutrix or to compensate the persons acquitted of the false rape charges. The court has rightly initiated proceddings against the prosecutrix u/s.344 Cr.PC for giving false evidence. The relevant portion from the said order is reproduced. 20I find it expedient to proceed against the prosecutrix u/s.344 Cr.PC for giving false evidence before this court, which is being done by way of a separate order. 21. I may further note that there is a dire need for provision to be made in the Code of Criminal Procedure to enable the court to direct either State or the prosecutrix or to compensate the persons acquitted of the false rape charges. In cases, where the court comes to conclusion that the accused had been implicated on totally false and baseless charges, the accused, in fact, is the victim and deserves to be compensated for the mental harassment, humiliation and physical torture caused to him in facing arrest, imprisonment and the ordeal of criminal trial. Rape is the most hated crime in the society. Persons accused of and arrested on the charges of rape lose every bit of honour, dignity and respect in the society and they are ostracized from the community. Nobody takes note of their acquittal, after the charges levelled against them turn to be false and fabricated. Such unfortunate persons certainly need to be compensated and SC No.154/13. Page 11 of 12rehabilitated. 22. At present, I do not find any provision in the Code of Criminal Procedure or any other law in force for the time being, empowering the court to grant compensation to the accused acquitted of the false criminal charges. Hence I consider that State should either amend Section 357 of the Code of Criminal Procedure or add a fresh section in the Code empowering the courts to grant compensation to the accused in such like cases. 23. A copy of this judgment be sent to the Secretary, Department of Law, Govt. of India and the Chairman, Law Commission of India for their perusal and consideration. Announced in open (VIRENDER BHAT) Court on 08.1.2014. Addl. Sessions Judge (Special Fast Track Court) Dwarka Courts, New Delhi.
Advertisement

Interesting content

merinews for RTI activists

Create email alerts

Total subscribers: 208716
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.