Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
  
Political Play
Zulfiqar Shah
Whom does Hindu exodus benefit in Pakistan? 20 August, 2012
Hindu Exodus has created a new debate around minority rights in Pakistan. Analyzing factors and repercussions as well as identifying losers-beneficiaries matrix can lead to understand the scenario ousting the indigenous community from their land.

BEGINNING OF the Hindu exodus last week proved to be a shaker of the governance foundations in Pakistan. The government, on one hand, rushed to resist a possible mass exodus, and on the other, it adopted denial jargons through its Interior Ministry and Sindh Government.

Exodus of Hindus from Sindh province, Pakistan is not an abrupt reaction of some action. In fact, a gradual exodus has been in the process since 1970s after the first and historically well discussed Hindu exodus during the partition of united India.

This gradual exodus is the result of multipronged policy of Pakistani governance structure to terrorize Hindus of Sindh so that their upper cast as well as elite and middle class especially from north of Sindh may migrate to India and elsewhere. Meanwhile, the poor and Dalit Hindus who are in majority population in the Southeast could either be converted to Islam through various Islamic Missionaries and Madersahs of Wahabism as well as Devband schools of thought. Hundreds of Madersas are operating in the India-bordering districts of Umerkot, Mithi, Sanghar and Ghotki - where majority of the Pakistani Hindus dwell.

The cases of forced conversions, abductions, assassinations, and forced marriages of Hindu girls have increased over last two decades in similar pattern to the increase of Madersahs. This is a beginning of Talbanization in Sindh, which is the only secular province of Pakistan and until now has protected its Sufi - secular credentials and defended itself against religious extremism.

There are some political factors also behind this. Hindu majority of Pakistan is traditional voters of Pakistan People’s Party (PPP), which is a liberal center-left populist party; therefore, the security establishment has always eyed it. Exodus of Hindus from Sindh can weaken PPP in at least ten districts of Sindh.

Besides, there are some other more important factors as well. Punjab is thickly populated province of Pakistan. It always has been shifting its populations to the rest provinces of the country and abroad. Meanwhile, emerging Punjabi and Pashtun trader and businesspersons needs new markets of investment. Khyber Pakhtunkhwa (KPK) and Balchistan are undergoing insurgency; however markets, trade and business in the majority districts of Sindh is led by Hindu mercantile, entrepreneur and investor. The exodus will service the population and business interests of Punjab and KPK. It will also lead to the first success of Taliban in Sindh. More horrific is the fact that it will convert Sindhi indigenous population of the province into the permanent minority in their historical land.

Sindhi feudal class is no doubt is monstrous but has never been fanatic. Its majority is still secular; however, those who are weaker in power in their constituencies, have aligned with the Mullahs. The emerging Sindhi middle class as well as traditional feudal in association with civil society, media and political parties including Sindhi nationalists have rejuvenated the Hindu rights and protection movement in Sindh after the hype of Hindu Exodus because they are secular and more then that it is in their political and ethnic interests.

Exodus is none’s interest -- neither India, nor Pakistan and Sindh. The only missing link is the realization of necessary change on the part of establishment. What is to be done then? The only way is the ruling elites and establishment of Pakistan need to review the country’s policies, legal framework, and so-called ideological notion towards Hindus and other minorities. If they avoid this noble task, time and nature will avoid them for sure.

About The Author
Zulfiqar is a political analyst, researcher and rights activist, having academic background of Philosophy and Development Studies. Organized and led massive movements of minorities and land rights in Sindh, Pakistan. Contributed with many dailies and weeklies in Pakistan and now contributing with some English dailies in Nepal and Afghanistan. Associated with The Institute for Social Movements, Pakistan; and currently based at Kathmandu, Nepal.
COMMENTS (6)
Guest
Name
Email Id
Verification Code
Raj kumar
Basically its conspiracy against whole Sindhi nation, to make them in minority in their own home land. According to 1998 census , Sindhi speaking are 60% in Sindh and from which 6% are Sindhi Hindu . If 6% population quit their mother land, it will become easy to make sSindhi in minority.
Preetama Das
The second last paragraph in the write up is a learning for me. I didnt know the facts. Thanks Mr. Zulfiqar Shah.
Salim
What these stupid extremists do not understand that these type of actions result in a reaction. The Hindus will now get united, nurture a extremist mentality and look for a right opportunity to get back. I completely agree with Mr. Shah that Pakistan needs to work towards empowering their minority communities. But with too much trouble at their hands, it seems a distant dream for the current Pak govt. to even think of acting on such issues.
Shakti Arora
I heard somebody once say that the Muslim community suffered not only during the participation but is still suffering now. Apparently it felt true. However the recent exodus of Hindus in Pakistan proves that everybody was and still is getting hurt. God knows how long we keep fighting only in the name of religion?
Amlan Tripathi
Mr. Shah, Great to read your write up. It gives an insight of how a real educated person from Pakistan will think. I just pray there are more like you and good sense prevail.
Md. Tajuddin
I agree to the fact that exodus is of nobody's interest BUT then sadly speaking when it comes to miscreants in Pak - I do not think they do things only bcoz it will be beneficial. They will do it only if it hurts India. Look at the recent disturbances they created in India by creating an agitation in Indian muslims by posting doctored images and messages on FB. I am not saying Indian muslims were innocent - they need to sit down, introspect and feel ashamed of the stupid act they have done for the past 10 days BUT that doesnt justify the wrong intentions the Pakis had.
merinews for RTI activists

Create email alerts

Total subscribers: 205636
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.