Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
Will the fog in the India-US skyway last the whole winter?
Even in the thick winter fog over New Delhi and probably New York on the new year eve, a few things stand out clear and shining in the Devayani Khobragade's, the Indian diplomat in the US, humiliation issue:

1. The US believed that Sangeetha, the domestic help of Devyani Khobragade, is a victim of human trafficking.

2. The US considered Indian legal system as untrustworthy.

India and the US are democratic countries where it is free to hold different opinions and beliefs. And India is in no position to influence the thinking of the world’s most powerful country (as referred to in a leading US newspaper edit on the Devyani's humiliation issue). So the US has every right to hold on to its beliefs.

But when it came to direct action, even a country like India could not remain unresponsive. And that is what happened in the Devayani humiliation case. When Devayani was arrested in a humiliating manner,  India could not accept the ‘standard procedure’ argument which left many intriguing questions unanswered, and keep quiet.

When it came to light that the husband and children of Sangeetha were flown to the US two days  prior to the arrest of  Devayani and when the Manhatten  attorney explained that the ‘evacuation’ was aimed at protecting them from legal action in India, India had to come to terms with the fact that it was the Govt. of India and not Devyani who is humiliated, in view of the following:

1. That the US considered Sangeetha as a human trafficking victim knowing  fully well that Sangeetha is an Indian citizen who travelled to the US on an Indian passport to serve an Indian diplomat there, leading to the inescapable inference that the US considered Govt. of India to be responsible for  the alleged human trafficking.

2. That the US thought it fit to ‘evacuate’ persons against whom proceedings were pending in a court in India; that a person of the status of Manhatten attorney had been vested with the power to act to thwart the legal proceedings of a high court in India and that he had been given the privilege to justify the act in a public statement.

Now that the psyche of India is severely wounded, the US has two clear options for future course of action based on whether the US acted due to a wrong reading of the facts or deliberately to punish India for its recent defiance in policy matters.

In case it is the latter, the US can continue with the legal action against Devyani, rebuke India for its demand for apology and retaliate against the cancellation of certain privileges enjoyed by  the US diplomats in India. This will send a strong message to the other countries  who will be reminded forcefully that might alone is right at least in international politics.

In case it is due to the wrong reading of facts, the US can  redeem the situation through the following steps:

1. Drop the case against Devyani.
2. Send  Sangeetha and her family back to India
3. Punish the officials who erred

This will go a long way in promoting better relations on lasting terms with India and a host of other countries who fall in the same category. And bring bright sunshine back to the calm winter skies over New Delhi and New York.

In fact the US can go a step further and apologise to India for trying to interfere with the Indian legal system and compensate Devyani for the humiliation which should have been avoided. But these things fall in the category of wishful thinking, not worth pursuing. Yet they cannot be ruled out. Who knows what the summer months or the falls portend.

Editorial NOTE: This article is categorized under Opinion Section. The views expressed in this article are solely those of the author and do not necessarily represent the views of In case you have a opposing view, please click here to share the same in the comments section.
Email Id
Verification Code
Email me on reply to my comment
Email me when other CJs comment on this article
Sign in to set your preference

Interesting content

merinews for RTI activists

Create email alerts

Total subscribers: 208206
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.