Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
With all due respect, My Lord, you are completely wrong
Last week Supreme Court judge AR Dave said that Indians should revert to their ancient traditions and texts such as Mahabharata and Bhagwad Gita should be introduced to children at an early age.

"Our old tradition is lost, if it had been there, we would not have had all these problems (violence and terrorism) in our country," Justice Dave said, speaking at an international conference in Ahmedabad.

The judge also suggested that Bhagwad Gita and Mahabharata should be introduced to students from the first standard. "Had I been the dictator of India, I would have introduced Gita and Mahabharata in class one. That is the way you learn how to live life. I am sorry if somebody says I am secular or I am not secular. But if there is something good, we have to get it from anywhere," the judge said.

Responding to Justice Dave's proposal, Press Council of India Chairman Markandey Katju said this was against India's secular feature and Constitution and would do it great harm.

Katju said, "I totally disagree with Justice Dave's statement that Gita and Mahabharat should be made compulsory in schools. In a country of such diversity as ours, nothing of this kind should be compelled or imposed, as that is against our nation's secular feature and Constitution," he said in a statement.

He said Muslims and Christians may not want their children to be taught these books and questioned if their children yet be forced to read them.

"Some people say that Gita only teaches morality and has nothing to do with religion. But Muslims may say that only the Quran teaches morality, Christians may say that only the Bible teaches morality, Sikhs may say that only the Guru Granth Saheb teaches morality, Parsis may say only the Zend Avesta teaches morality, etc," he said.

In Mahabharat, Arjun was arguing against war with Lord Krishna. He said, "Many a young Sudra warriors will die. After war, their widowed women will cohabitate with upper varna men and have children. This will disturbance the orderliness in the society."

Will Justice Dave endorse this archaic opinion just because it is from Mahabharat? Class one students can't even read & write. How can you impose such burden on them?

If indeed he has said this, then that is completely wrong. Can you give religious education in schools and that too regarding one religion? It's given in our constitution that each religion has equal rights.

Earlier the chairman of Indian council of Historical Research said that the caste system worked well in ancient India. Should a sitting Supreme Court judge join the band wagon of such feudal elements?

Email Id
Verification Code
Email me on reply to my comment
Email me when other CJs comment on this article
Sign in to set your preference
merinews for RTI activists

Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.