Submit :
News                      Photos                     Just In                     Debate Topic                     Latest News                    Articles                    Local News                    Blog Posts                     Pictures                    Reviews                    Recipes                    
  
India : THE DEBATE PAGE : DEBATE
Do you think Dr Rajesh Talwar killed Aarushi (on whom he doted) and Hemraj?
The police arrested Dr Rajesh Talwar in connection with the twin murder case. The brutal murder shook the nation. The police fudged the investigation and was under great pressure. Still there are many loopholes in the case, which has the entire nation gasped in utter disbelief. Noida police had to face flak. When Aarushi Talwar was found murdered in her house last week, the prime suspect was Talwar's domestic help, Hemraj, who was missing. Instead of acting as competent investigative team, the police just went on saying that it was an 'open and shut case,' a dead body and a missing servant. Just when the police was about to declare that they have solved the mystery, a retired police officer discovered Hemraj's dead body on the terrace of Talwar's residence. On May 23, the police arrested Dr Rajesh Talwar, alleging him of committing the murders after discovering a conversation tape between Dr Talwar and his lawyer, wherein, the former had asked his lawyer to file an anticipatory bail in the court. Dr Talwar was believed to have indulged in adultery with his colleague, Dr Anita Durrani. It was made out to be a crime of passion, where the daughter and the domestic help were in the know of it all. IGP, Meerut range, told the reporters that Dr Talwar found his daughter in an 'objectionable situation, but not compromising' with Hemraj and in a fit of rage he killed both of them. Just when the police was about to heave a sigh of relief, the credibility of the investigating agencies took a further beating with the IG accused of character assassination of two dead people. Moreover, there are many question, which points the needle of suspicion towards Dr Rajesh Talwar like: Why didn't he sack Hemraj, if he knew about his daughter's growing intimacy with him? After discovering her body in the morning, instead of informing the police, why did he called his relatives first? What were Talwar's doing on the night of the murders? Why did Hemraj feel that his life was in danger? Why did he continue working with the Talwars? Why did the Talwars keep the blood stained mattress on their neighbour's terrace? Why the Talwars hurried in cremating Aarushi's body, a vital link in investigating the case? Who answered the call on Hemraj's mobile when the milkman called? Dr Nupur Talwar rubbished the police theory. Dr Anita Durrani and her husband declined any illicit relation with Dr Talwar. The case is murkier. Do you think Dr Rajesh Talwar killed Aarushi (on whom he doted) and Hemraj?
RESULTS
Agree :
66.19%
Disagree :
33.81%
Agree : 66.19 %
anil nair | Nov 30, 2013
how can a servant is authorised to have drinks at night with his friends when u have a 14yrold daughter sleeping next door when a person drinks his psychology can take devil brain and under such circumstances can do anything
manu | May 26, 2012
think aarushi and hemraj were in a compromising position,seeing this DR.Rajesh might have got angry and killed them....dr rajesh was rich and hemraj was thr domestic help...rajesh might have feared that,in future hemraj would tell about his(hemraj) n aarushi's affair...which hemraj could have miss used...in fear rajesh might have killed hemraj...in anger might have killed aarushi....
Lavar | Jun 12, 2011
Tanhks for sharing. What a pleasure to read!
gandu | Jun 04, 2011
action happened like this... Hemraj was angry that Rajesh was doing incest on his daughter, so that he got a golf stick, and decided to hit Rajesh, the next time he tries to do incest. he kept the stick in his room. unfortunately the golf stick hit Arushi, who came in between. Rajesh got angry and he snatched the stick and hit hemraj however he could not save his daughter, he hatched a plan to escape murder, and tried to clean up the act.
malik | Jun 01, 2011
the question should be who killed arushi and who killed hemraj. It can be a separate question; or the same. kareena question is correct,, parents should advertise money(1 crore +) to get investigative leads from the public.
kareena shah | Jun 01, 2011
hey Karishma ;;;, how are you sure the murderers are not the parents? what is your level of confidence that it is a very small possibility. without going thru the analysis?, you cannot say like this.. dont accuse government of negligiance, when parents themselves absolve all thought process of the murder, parents only say CBI should find, it..? ... what is this nonsense. as guardian, the least they could have done is to set an advertisement that they are willing to pay 2 crores of rupees to find the murderor?
sumit | May 22, 2011
Rajesh is the culprit,, why would murderers drink whiskey in house,, and not run off.... Were they waiting to kill the others too ????... if so, why did the murderers not open the parents room, and kill them too? they were supposed to be sleeping,, this should not take long time,,,, if murderers had killed 2 people in 1 hour, then they could have killed 2 more in another hour,, and drink whiskey to the hearts content.
j8888 | May 09, 2011
Rajesh killed both Aarushi & Hemraj he should be punished.
sunita | May 09, 2011
Rajesh talwar killed both of them & impressed all top people to hide the crime & he did not allow to get the police sniffer dogs
jay | May 03, 2011
Rajesh Talwar did killed both arushi and hemraj his wife is accomplice
MUNNA | Apr 29, 2011
i think that arushi father had killed her and mother had supported him
madhu | Apr 23, 2011
how come Arushi is listed as non-virgin in the CBI report? and how come it is so for 13 year old girl?
jimmie | Apr 15, 2011
since,3 years v r waiting for the result of Arushi n their worker murder case.
nepali | Apr 15, 2011
Rajesh is porabably the only suspect. Hemraj was a very good person, who was killed too.
sunita | Apr 12, 2011
100% father killed both
amrita sharma | Apr 02, 2011
Talwars are guilty of killing Arushi & Hemraj, if it was anybody else they would have solved the murder long ago ,all the top officials were hand in glove to protect talwars.
saurabh | Mar 31, 2011
i m agree only her father can killed her.
Prachi Tiwari | Mar 30, 2011
i m also sure that arushi is killed only by her father mr. rajesh talwar
mathur | Mar 29, 2011
not quite,, it was Hemraj who was caught by Rajesh, who murdered him
IBM | Mar 29, 2011
It might be a case on INCEST. Father might be responsible for murder.
arvi | Mar 24, 2011
get the case closed asap
Asfar Siddiqui | Mar 22, 2011
Aarushi Parents are hiding the truth, there must be some reason behind Aarushi Murder & her parents are very much aware about the fact.
Asfar Siddiqui | Mar 22, 2011
Aarushi Parents are hiding the truth, there must be some reason behind Aarushi Murder & her parents are very much aware about the fact.
arushi | Mar 20, 2011
u kill me also. ha ha ha ha joking
vinod | Mar 19, 2011
yes , rajesh talwar
Pawan | Mar 19, 2011
Aarushi is been killed rajesh talwar and nupur talwar have all information they both are lying .rajesh talwar killed bot aaarushi and hemraj
sunil | Mar 17, 2011
Rajesh talwar has killed both aarushi and hemraj in the fit of rage.
akdikshit | Mar 08, 2011
We should not come to final conclusion so quickly. I am however in doubt about the role of Aarushi's mother. Whom does she want to save? Her husband or someone else?
IBM USA | Mar 04, 2011
I agree on supernova's suggestion. that is the only correct answer
supernova | Mar 03, 2011
Answers ----------- 1. Rajesh used to have incest with daughter 2. Hemraj a good person understood it but could do nothing to prevent it hence he tried to get in touch with social worker. 3. Rajesh drugged wife on the night so that she will get concentrated sleep 4. Rajesh went ahead with his activities after gifting camera to daughter. 5. Hemraj being a good man, tried to prevent it, he was hit by a golf stick, however mistakenly the golf stick also hit Arushi, she died. Arushi came in between and got hit. 6. Hemraj was brutally hit on the head multiple times. 7. Body was moved to terrace by 1 person using bedsheet, and dragged, it cannot be two person, because no dragging will be required in this case. 8. blood of Hemraj was removed and cleaned. in Arushis room. except for bed mattress. 9. Rajesh moved Hemrajs body to terrace to get an excuse so that he can do cleanup time. terrace was locked for this purpose. 10. Nupur could not realize any issue because she did not think hard, and how the key to Arushis room got out from under her pillow. 7.
santosh | Mar 03, 2011
i think talwar himself not killed his daughter but hire someone that killed his daughter. and destruct are the evidence. the hand print on wall only for the turn the police. router are closed by talwar. tarwar want to killed aarushi because aarushi had sex with hamraj
parth | Mar 01, 2011
Hi all, Don't u all know that Aarushi is an IVF(In-Vitro Fertilised) child to Talwars..
Suman | Mar 01, 2011
no intruder will have keys of terrace/home, or lock the terrace or drag the body to terrace, or drink alcohol, or leave Arushis room key in house. or not ring bell, or have the front door open, or not call Hemraj and yet get in, Facts: Hemraj and Arushi were murdered in the complex. however no blood of Hemraj were found in house but drag marks were found on the staircase, which might mean that the blood was cleaned, and no intruder will waste time to clean any blood, also the front grill door can always be locked form inside through practice.. the chances of Hemraj being killed in terrace are slim because he will scream first however it can happen. Case scenario 1: Hemraj and Arushi found in objectonable state. and Rajesh requests Hemraj to go to Terrace. He then questions Arushi on what is actually happening, and threatening Arushi to tell him privately on it. however in the spur of moment after getting response , he kills arushi in fit of rage, and again goes to Terrace to talk with Hemraj and kills him too, He then comes down and informs his wife, who do the clean up of Arushis room later. Since the cut injury on neck has not propogated blood everywhere, it is done after death, and blood flow had stopped. Case 2: Same a 1 except Hemraj Arushi murdered in Arushis room, and body of Hemraj dragged to Terrace. there is slim chances of any outsider entering a secured building where he can be recognized or caught.
madhavdiyal | Mar 01, 2011
parents only the culprits
pyare mohan | Mar 01, 2011
questions to think of. 1. why was the terrace door locked. and did anyone know/see the lock earlier. who had bought the lock? 2. Did anyone possess the keys of the terrace lock? 3. where was the keys for the terrace lock stored if available 4. How did the keys of front door of house get stolen? where were they stored? 5. how come keys of Arushis' room were found, but not of the house?
Abhinav Shukla | Feb 28, 2011
yes
sacha kumar | Feb 27, 2011
I know who is the killer. I take pledge in God, and implore him, that the killer is hanged. curse be to murderer ,and all his supporters who have done such a vile deed. may his education and experience elude him at a crucial juncture so that he is defeated.
vips | Feb 26, 2011
Rajesh talwar may hve found hemraj and aarushi in a objectionable position(followd her orkut scraps from beginnin and seems she has a lot of boyfrenz..as allways in DPS).....in the spur of moment he might hve killed them....what a Shame on the parents...
rose | Feb 25, 2011
If the father has not killed the daughter, atleast he would like to know who killed his daughter. There is no sign showing that he is least bothered to know the killers. How is it possible, the parents are sleeping in the same house and some unknown people entering the house and killing the daughter. no one on earth can believe this. If he has not killed, why he is not pressurising the epartment to find the killers, instead he went on to do the last rituals
srishti | Feb 23, 2011
i think that rajesh talwar killed aarushi
parshu | Feb 21, 2011
my take on this. get a plea bargain, with Nupur, and set her free, accuse her only for destruction of evidence. that way we can catch the real culprit.
great Kalki | Feb 21, 2011
1. Arushi's body had frontal damage on the head, and there was no resistance with the attacker implying as known to her or too fast action 2. Hemrajs body had rear damage on the head, so there was no resistance. 3. Arushis body was cleaned. 4. Arushis did not possess virgin hymen and had no bruises 5. Attackers cannot drink alcohol in house, but will run away 6. Attackers will not drag body of Hemraj to terrace and waste time in doing it. 7. no bell was rung at 12:00 o clock in the night, 8. Gurkha says no one entered the building or went out in the night. 9. no belongings were stolen. 10. the body was cremated and ashes taken away to some other location to eat the time at crucial juncture 11. the rooms were cleaned which should not have done 12. the staircase were wiped of stains, no outsider can do this within the murder time frame. Note : no sniffer dogs were used or camera recording done which is bad police investigation
shipra sharma | Feb 20, 2011
If the murderer was from outside then he /she would have run immediately after the task. No need of doing further changes in the crime scene. Some one did so to hide his/ her involvement. Why will the murderer come back in the house from the terrace and lock it ,,, after placing Hemraj's body there . Something fishy.. Why are the stairs wiped and cleaned . The terrace locked?
Anonymous | Feb 20, 2011
Completely agree. Talwars are in full knowledge of who and why committed the crime. Shame on them. I heard that Shobha De questioned that if Nupur is the biological mother. I wouldn't be surprised if she isn't it.
ramana | Feb 18, 2011
please donot say that she might be an adopted daughter.for normal people there will be no difference between biological child and adopted child in fact it is more than that. a criminal brain can do anything even for his biological child. i think arushi saw some thing which she should not. after killing her, again they murdered the victim of arushi's murder that is hemraj.
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
Rajesh and Nupur Talwar to save their own skin are contorting stories about their dead daughter's character and her having illicit relations with the man servant. The man servant would not have gone in scared state of mind to a social worker USha if he was involved - he would have simply run away. Infact Hemraj may have tried to protect Aarushi's life from her parents. Parents Rajesh and Nupur are DISGUSTING to say the least. They really stop at nothing
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
News channels reported that Rajesh and Nupur cell phome records show that they were awake on cell phone calls right through the night. That is proof that they did not sleep through the murders.
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
Please get somone to check if aarushi is really their own blood child or adopted or something
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
Wikipedia is reporting that enough evidence is there with CBI to actually sentence Rajesh adn Nupur Talwar to hang. Wikipedia says - since Rajesh/Nupur is the father/mother and India is a conservative country where family relations are valued CBI is not sentencing him for hang till death. This is wrong people should know the truth. Also just because it is family should they be let off scot free- is that not setting a wrong example to Indian society? especially in a situation where it is more than obvious that parents have murdered to probably hide some crime of their's
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
Hemraj could not have had any physical relation with Aarushi. Infact he may have tried to protect Aarushi like his child and hence went to Usha the social activist. Some news channels also mentioned that Hemraj made blank calls to CBI but spoke nothing. Hemraj may have become aware of something like incest that Aarushi's father may be doing to her since childhood and Aarushi after becoming a teenager may have realised the gravity of the situation and confided in Hemraj. If Hemraj was scared only for himself he could have simply run away. Hemraj lost his life in protecting Aarushi from her insane and soulless parents. The fact that Aarushi parts had been washed, and the opening was found very large, and no resistance marks meant no forced rape -but may be her father was abusing her since childhood and she was not aware that this is a form of abuse till she became a teenager. It is sad that her parents to escape punishment are actually killing dead Aarushi's reputation also. The truth no matter how heinous should come out so that children know that parents are not God and children need to be careful of parents.
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
Why has some one not yet looked at a cult killing angle to it by the parents. Many cults in the world encourage incest since chldhood and eventual killing on puberty.
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
Yes, both father and mother have done it. Not just father alone. Maybe even Dinesh Talwar is involved otherwise why would he make calls to alter post mortem reports.
ipsiray@yahoo.com | Feb 16, 2011
Why does some news channel / police/ CBI not run a sting operation on Aarushi's parents. That way they will get proof of their crime and motive also.
sonia | Feb 15, 2011
Why does everybody think that arushi was killed in her room.I think Arushi was killed by rajesh talwar together with hemraj at the terrace. her body was then shifted to her bedroom later.this explains blood marks on stairs.blood soaked matress on terrace. her parts were cleaned and hence the room was found in orderly condition. it was an honour killing. parents know about it. hemraj body was left on the terrace as they could not dispose it off outside. they locked the terrace and thought of doing so later. they cannot reveal this to anybody. also nupur being amothet will not reveal this as this will lead to bad name for her daughter too. Hemraj was an old servant , he must have used emotional blacmail etc and as regularly forcing himself on the child and she must have been consenting. these things do happen
fouzia | Feb 15, 2011
shameless parents, how can they keep a servant inside the house.
Naina | Feb 15, 2011
I agree. Also is there a possibility that Aarushi was not his daughter?
Gary | Feb 14, 2011
I have completely read the CBI report. There is no doubt in my mind that Dr. Rajesh Talwar killed both Aarushi and Hemraj in a fit of rage after accidentally finding them involved in some kind of sexual activity in the middle of the night. He was working till 12.00 or so and then has visited his daughter's room for some reason. Meanwhile Aarushi has let Hemraj inside her room. They are engaged in some kind of sexual act if not full penetration. Dr Dinesh Talwar has seen the unexpected upon entering the the Aarushi's room and in an impulsive moment and fit of rage has taken the golf club and hit Aarushi first and Hemraj next both dying instantaneous deaths. Then he must have woken up his wife and the couple must have gone through very difficult hours trying to digest the enormity of mistake he has committed. I do sympathize for Dr. Dinesh Talwar as this was committed in a fit after seeing his only daughter just 14 engaged in sexual activity with a much older servant. But he is the killer.
amit | Feb 12, 2011
They are shameless parents. Every day they are coming on camera after killing their only child. Every day they are coming on different channel some time on start,ndtv,zee tv,news24 ,headline etcs. Yaar kuchh to sharam karo.
Dipin Nevpane | Feb 12, 2011
There is no doubt Mr and Mrs Talwar are involved.The circumstantial evidences dont lie...They need to be punished soon for their crime!!!
Samuel | Feb 11, 2011
There is no doubt in my mind that Dr Talwar killed aarushi.The point is let us take the point they are non guilty. Well Rajesh talwar is on phone till 12. his daugter gets killed in between 12 to 1 and he doesnot even know as he gets down in sound sleep in a hour. The murderer gets in, kills aarushi,kills hemraj, enjoys whisky, lifts hemraj to terrace, closes the door and gets away.Now i will not take that theory. Not a single all by for Mr Talwar. His friends, maid, driver, painter, the police, two police teams, CBI all are against him. Now we dont expect a parent to kill his kid, so thats the issue. Even I dont know what was the reason. But if the circumstantial evidences are kept as the prime facie evidence, Dr Talwar is in trouble.I think they know the truth, and should speak now.
praneeth | Feb 11, 2011
no doubt rajesh talwar killed. both of them....hatsoff to UTSAV SHARMA...for doin wat most of us thot of...
shashi | Feb 11, 2011
in my opinion dr. Rajesh talwar is the murderer of his daughter. He should be punished.
rajesh | Feb 11, 2011
very first day when I read the news papers and after readinf 2-3 days more in the news .....My verdict was Parents killed Arushi Nobody else. 1. Parents were sleeping in the room beside to Arushi but they were unknown about the whole incidents , duration of the act of murder and shaving her private parts and dragging their servent to the rooftop and cleaning the stairs took 2-3 hours at least and .....friends ....If you have seen the face of the RAJESH TALWAR AND NUPUR's..thier face itself tella that they are the murderer ..........our constitution asks for proof which has been removed , but still there is a lot of things which will prove that RAJESH TALWAR killed his daughter for his honour.....It is an honor killing nothing else
Sandeep | Feb 11, 2011
He has done the master murder and get away with it ..but little did he realized that there are crucial circumstantial evidence , he has left it ..He is a very crooked father ..
Jitesh | Feb 10, 2011
yes it is confirmed by CBI closure report.
Rajiv | Feb 10, 2011
circumstantial evidence is against outsiders, why will outsiders who murder will drag the body of Hemraj to Terrace? that is really confusing
ag | Feb 10, 2011
surely,parents did it.
raju | Feb 09, 2011
It is more likely both parents are involved. BTW Nupur Talwar is more likely to be the murderer in a fit of anger than Rajesh Talwar, who provided a supporting role... we will never know who played supporting and who took the lead, in the spur of moment.
Raj | Feb 09, 2011
Rajesh Talwar is the killer. Close relatives know that, but supprting him because Talwar's are rich and money can buy anything in this world. It was not a planned murder it was like on the spur of the moment little accidents happened which went out of control leading to all the killngs. The fact that the girl's body was throughly cleaned by chemical and dressed up shows the parents hand. But Nupur Talwar may be innocent but supporting Rajesh Talwar because as I already told you money can buy anything.
xyz | Feb 09, 2011
Yes he did kill his daughter.
Shiraz | Feb 08, 2011
Both the talwars are hiding the facts about the murder of their and moreover, are cleverly playing with media. The mother is too smart to get. I strongly believe that bot are involved in muder.
UBk | Feb 08, 2011
Yes Dr. Talwar is very smart he may has killed both Aarushi and Hemraj.
ME | Feb 04, 2011
Its very apparent. Talwar is the culprit. All the evidence denotes his callous killing of his daughter. He is trying to hide behind by conducting rallies and pressurising the CBI on evidence.
Anonymous | Jan 29, 2011
I have never seen a set of parents so little grieved by their daughter's death...I have heard their interviews on tv, they always evade directly answering the question or getting into details of the day it happened. They always make careful and rehearsed statements...CBI seems to be under pressure to not to declare Rajesh Talwar as the culprit... I have absolutely no doubt that parents are involved...
xyz | Jan 28, 2011
to look at it astrologically,parents can be immediately seen as culpable. Both have highly afflicted birth charts and of dubious morality.But astrology even if it shows such heightened tendencies,is not acceptable by the court of law.The dubious morality as presented by birth chart can throw some light on the wife swapping incident. An insider also tells of aarushi being a surrogate child,born quite late to the couple,What else explains tampering with evidence,parents rushing to haridwar to scatter the ashes merely hours after discovery of crime? If court cannot prove still through evidnce,the divine law and cosmic justice surely will.
Saba Siddique | Jan 26, 2011
I have no doubt that both parents are the killers. I also believe that the family has rallied together to put up a brave (brazen) front after having bribed the corrupt NOIDA police to remove valuable evidence. I pray and hope both of them are given the punishment they truly deserve.
vasudev akundi | Jan 25, 2011
The sheer absence of any other suspect is evidence enough to accuse Rajesh talwar. This is clearly an honour killing...it is highly possible that Arushi had physical relationship with Hemraj...Rajesh talwar was enraged when he saw them "in action" killed both of them to save family honour. clear and simple.
vijay | Jan 10, 2011
Yes .. Several reasons . First thing , noida police dint pick up sufficient leads before arresting . This gave talwars a upper hand . They then whitewashed the crime site leaving less or no clues. This cannot be done by anyone else except the family. If talwars were not guilty i am sure they would have taken on all people and media head on . After all they have v good support from family and lawyers . Also to notice , the talwars appear to media very selectively and talk very selectviely and minimal . This raises serious doubts . The above are Add-ONs to the CBI closure which itself speak many things . Pretty sure that either they have done it or they know all about it . It cant be possible without their knowledge atleast .
Sandhya | Jan 08, 2011
Just because it is difficult to digest the fact that a father cannot murder his own child dosent mean it never happens. nobody could have entered the flat at night and only murder the child and the servant. if robbery was the case then everyone should have been murdered. rajesh talwar seems to exhibit suspicious body language during interview..same applies for nupur talwar. they obv know more.
Raj | Jan 07, 2011
Any Parent who lock their own daughter every day, and a spouse parent supporting this behavior is an immediate indicator of extreme suspicious behavior, A violent personality would only exhibit such qualities. The sequence must have happened like this.. 10:30 pm Parents and Arushi eat at table. 11:00 Arushis parents go to room to retire 11:15 Rajesh goes to visit bathroom, and sees Arushis door open, he investigates but finds something which arouses violent behaviour, He hits with a golf stick, however the blow fall on Arushis head, and she goes into coma...remember she has not died... 11:30 Rajesh calls his brother and asks him his advice.. 11:45 Rajesh Hemraj drink alcohol. 12:00 Rajesh gets again violent and hits Hemraj after accusing him of the reason Arushi is unconcios. he closes internet connections 12:30 Hemraj dead, Arushi dead. 12:45 Operation cleanup....Nupur uses surgical instruments to cut neck. Rajesh cannot do this due to his violent nature. 1:00 to 3:00 both cannot sleep and do cleanup, and move Hemrajs body to terrace. 4:00 both sleep after confirming plans, 6:00 clock,,, Nupur requests sevant to come up by throwing keys. 6:30 calls police 7:00 police come... 7:30 Police told to look for Hemraj, at railway station :- ) 8:00 to 9:00 Operation super cleanup.
Anonymous | Jan 03, 2011
The Talwars are definitely involved in the murder of their own daughter. They should have the courage to own it and come out in the open.
Kishan Prasad P | Jan 02, 2011
Perhaps (Purely guess, based on circumstances) Mrs.Nupur Talwar would have involved herself in any EM relationship (God should Pardon if I am wrong) with someone very closely or Dr Talwar himself may be a part of the Multiple relationship game of spouse swap cases which are normal in the so called highly placed societies. On knowing of this by the little girl, the whole incident would have brought both Mrs and Mr Talwar to very bad in the mind of little girl; to such an extent that they would have decided to get rid of their own kid because some times these sexual relations are very dicey to the extent the people may be mentally forced to resort to unruly and weird actions. This (I am purely guessing) may be the motive behind murder if at all both Dr and Mrs Talwar are involved. Since the murder has just happened in the very next room, no parent would ever allow any outsider to come inside that too into the room of a young girl. CBI should concentrate on knowing life style and friends and social circle of doctor friends and social contacts to know their correct background. This may give some insight into clues for cracking the mystery of murder.
Anjani | Jan 01, 2011
Talwars either killed both of them or they know the killer. They are shedding crocodile tears on TV.
sahil | Jan 01, 2011
who else ?
Mayank Gupta | May 15, 2010
rajesh talwar and his wife killed both of them
| Oct 13, 2009
| Jul 15, 2008
talwars and durrani have killed both. though CBI has given clean chit to talwar, it is true that they have killed. the servants are just scapegoats. talwars and durranis have killed yes they have killed.
dd | May 31, 2008
sdfs
peace | May 29, 2008
Well, this murder could have been done by Dr Talwar's compounder, who saw the entire family at night at the dining table. It is done by someone who knows whereabouts about the household. No parents can kill their children, no matter what it is. Police need to probe more into this. If surgical weapons are used, they need to interrogate Dr Rajesh's clinic staff as well and check on the finger prints in Arushi's and Hemraj's room. Hope, they find the culprit very soon.
abc | May 29, 2008
jhghjg
GBFGBFG | May 29, 2008
dfgdfgdf
Prathyash K Mathew | May 27, 2008
Dr.Talwar is most wanted culprit of arushi murder case why the police hiding & protecting Dr talwar ? Am not teaching police or any investigator or am not blaming any one any way am forced to ask police & investigators .... it is clearly said tht both hemaraj & arushi was killed by using surgical instruments ....if it was an outsider who comes for robery they wont or not at all use surgical instruments as mentioned..to kill them Hemaraj wont kill arushi bcoz he was working as a servant for many yrs with talwar family Now one more question to the police ..where is most wanted evidence ie the moblie phone records and show the correct post marttom report details Now if police is going to answer these questions most wanted culprit of arushi murder case will come out One of the most important proof of this case is moblie phone call records:: verify call records and we can see who did this and also the another most important thing is postmorttom reports plz chk the time when arushi and hemaraj was killed and now chk phone call details of Dr Talwar and remember if a crime is done some way or the other there will be a proof GOD keeps it !!! lets wait and see PRATHYASH K MATHEW
Disagree : 33.81 %
Anonymous | Oct 30, 2013
I think Hemraj killed Aarushi and Rajesh Talwar woke up hearing the noise. Seeing that Hemraj killed Aarushi, Rajesh killed Hemraj in fit of rage. He might have killed him in the terrace. Nupur and he must have cried over Aarushi all night and dressed up the crime scene. It is only the Talwars who know the truth.
nunu | Jun 14, 2011
i am brother to Rajesh Talwar, I dont think Rajesh can do such a thing. He is innocent. He has not murdered Arushi. Rajesh is being maligned unnecessary. he can do other bad things, but not mrder.
Kumar | Jun 14, 2011
What rubbish. So much of what is written is not fact at all. Adultery with Anita Durrani? Arushi intimate with Hemraj? No evidence of either.
rajah | Jun 04, 2011
hemraj was killed on terrace, after arushi go hit by golf stick earlier. hemraj was requested to go on terrace, and wait... however due to anger he was killed on terrace.
nunu | Jun 04, 2011
cbi should retake all fingerprints of all members and relatives of people in the housing society
moti | Jun 01, 2011
for all murder cases, the victims should always be buried, this should be enacted as a law.
Karishma S. Shah | May 30, 2011
For one second, imagine that you are the father of a 13-year girl who has been murdered. Imagine the grief. And then- imagine not only having to deal with guilt and immense grief of that BUT also with the accusation that you did it. So yes, there is a very very small possibility that it could have been the Talwars but till you're a 100% damn sure, on the ground of humanity, don't just talk through your a**. One day this could be you and just because of a negligent government you could be dealing with this. Take a moment to understand the case and its nuances and then create a judgement. The Talwars did not kill Arushi their 13-year-old daughter.
akash | May 22, 2011
who are we to agree or disagree, we dont know who killed her...!!! however we can only pray... to God... God ,, please do NOT forgive this crime,,,regardless if the murderer asks for forgiveness from you......this murderer/s should be punished!!!!! since it is gross and hurt the minds of millions of people.... please destroy the murderer,,, may the evil ones ROT in this current life and all future lives... ::::: Curve be to the murderer ,, all his accomplices, their mothers, fathers, and all their descendents. may they be cursed and rot in hell
Rajesh Gajra | May 16, 2011
I disagree because each and every piece of circumstantial evidence that points accusingly at the parents lack substantiation. Moreover, since there is no transparancy, and no substantiated facts, behind any accusation that can be conclusively said to make the parents as strong suspects.
Prasad | May 14, 2011
mr.talwar not to killed Aarushi
sam | May 04, 2011
i dont think that a father can be hard enough to kill his only daughter n if this news is so true n he he cant controlled his anger on d situation than he definetly killed hemraj first
suma | Apr 22, 2011
Eventhough i say Rajesh has not murdered Arushi,, I am begining to understand the analysis and he is only a possible suspect
Cerin Thiakan | Apr 21, 2011
its extremely shameful the way Noida police had handled this case at the beginning. They are the only reason y this case i think would never be cracked. We have no right to question the Talwars loyalty or even as i read below Hemraj sexuality. Thats horrible. I cannot say Talwars are innocent, but i kinda feel so because i have seen their interviews in numerous channels. They have given solid replies to each and every question put to them. Afterall they are parents and from the photographs of Arushis childhood we get to know they were a very happy family. Talwars have got good reputation among their patients and friends. So its true they are not people with criminal mindset. Do you think a dad if had killed his daughter out of a split second thought can hold on so long(even after being stabbed on his face) without giving even a small hint. Even a serial killer may not be able to do that. Second reason i support Talwars is, they have been pleading to the CBI to conduct the Touch DNA test. Why are the officials not ready to do that. If that is the only thing left to do why not do it. And as i read below one of the posts rightly said, if the parents really wanted to kill their daughter they could have found out much better ways of doing it without giving any clue at all. And if the murder was a slit second thought of outrage then they would not be capable to defend themselves for 3 years the way they are doing now. Whateva, i hope justice is done to Arushi. Be it her parents or any culprit from outside, whatever possible should be done to bring the killer out in public. God Bless Arushi and her soul
tv | Mar 25, 2011
hemraj is responsbile probably,, law should hold him accountable.. even if he is dead,, he is responsible.
matru | Mar 21, 2011
there is no third radiobutton for agree and disagree. button.... incest does happen all over the world. it is around 5%. in India nothing gets reported. it is high probability that Rajesh was involved in some issue. He know something. Dad is involved probably.
Ranjana | Mar 18, 2011
People like Rajesh and Nupur dont go round killing people let alone their daughters. And those who believe they did commit the horrific murders dont really know why they do.
manu | Mar 12, 2011
someone from the building is responsible. police should take fingerprints of all people from the building complex. This is required. How did the CBI not get the fingerprints of all people from the complex.?
uday ydav | Mar 09, 2011
CBI is investigating the Arushi, Hemraj murder case without success because they are sure that doctor Rajesh and Nupur Talwar are the murderers of their only daughter. I request you to enquire if CBI had suspected Hemraj as a homosexual and developed some theory accordingly. I have watched most programmes on Aarushi, Hemraj murder mystery on TV but till now I have not come across a debate where Hemraj’s sexuality is questioned. Until now no one has suspected whether Hemraj was homosexual but you treat him as a homosexual and you get all the answers to this 3 year old mystery. I have a theory that is based on his sexuality. I suspect Hemraj Banjade was a homosexual person who always tried to attract new youths in the locality. He used to lure the youths to come on the terrace after midnight when Talwar family is fast asleep. He used to sleep on the terrace. Many times he kept his mattress on the terrace. I also suspect that Krishna, Rajkumar and many others knew that Hemraj was homosexual and many of them must have reached Talwar family’s terrace many times to seek sex pleasure that Hemraj was only eager to give. But one day Krishna’s one acquaintance came to Noida and met Krishna. In no time the New Comer came to know about Hemraj. Hemraj also, quick to know about the New Comer, lured him to Talwar’s terrace in the night. According to me this new comer has murdered Aarushi and Hemraj because the fingerprints found at three different places [Talwar’s house, Talwar’s terrace and Krishna’s bed] belongs to one person and that person is not identified yet. The way he murdered them he must be very violent and cold blooded nature. On 16 May 2008, past 12.00 in the night, the New Comer knocked on the terrace door of the Talwar family, as a signal to Hemraj. Hemraj was in the talwar’s home waiting for the same. He climbed the staircase, opened the door and both of them went to the mattress already laid on the terrace. After this New Comer didn’t go away as every other one used to go. He wanted something that was in the house and Hemraj would not let him go inside the house at any cost. He wanted whisky. Hemraj objected to New Comer’s demand. They quarreled silently. But ultimately New Comer entered the house and came down the staircase. Hemraj objected to everything he did in silence. It was past 2.30 am, and Aarushi was still awake in her bedroom, stuck to her computer. She heard something and she came out and murder took place. One other angle is this. When New Comer and Hemraj were on the terrace, Hemraj fell asleep for a while. New Comer saw this as an opportunity to enter the house and came down in search of whisky. At this moment Aarushi came out of her bedroom and New Comer hit her. At this moment Hemraj came down. New Comer hit Hemraj also. Aarushi and Hemraj became unconscious. He drank enough whisky. He slit Aarushi’s throat, took Hemraj on the terrace on the mattress, slit his throat and fled. This is my theory. Uday S. Yadav
uday ydav | Mar 09, 2011
CBI is investigating the Arushi, Hemraj murder case without success because they are sure that doctor Rajesh and Nupur Talwar are the murderers of their only daughter. I request you to enquire if CBI had suspected Hemraj as a homosexual and developed some theory accordingly. I have watched most programmes on Aarushi, Hemraj murder mystery on TV but till now I have not come across a debate where Hemraj’s sexuality is questioned. Until now no one has suspected whether Hemraj was homosexual but you treat him as a homosexual and you get all the answers to this 3 year old mystery. I have a theory that is based on his sexuality. I suspect Hemraj Banjade was a homosexual person who always tried to attract new youths in the locality. He used to lure the youths to come on the terrace after midnight when Talwar family is fast asleep. He used to sleep on the terrace. Many times he kept his mattress on the terrace. I also suspect that Krishna, Rajkumar and many others knew that Hemraj was homosexual and many of them must have reached Talwar family’s terrace many times to seek sex pleasure that Hemraj was only eager to give. But one day Krishna’s one acquaintance came to Noida and met Krishna. In no time the New Comer came to know about Hemraj. Hemraj also, quick to know about the New Comer, lured him to Talwar’s terrace in the night. According to me this new comer has murdered Aarushi and Hemraj because the fingerprints found at three different places [Talwar’s house, Talwar’s terrace and Krishna’s bed] belongs to one person and that person is not identified yet. The way he murdered them he must be very violent and cold blooded nature. On 16 May 2008, past 12.00 in the night, the New Comer knocked on the terrace door of the Talwar family, as a signal to Hemraj. Hemraj was in the talwar’s home waiting for the same. He climbed the staircase, opened the door and both of them went to the mattress already laid on the terrace. After this New Comer didn’t go away as every other one used to go. He wanted something that was in the house and Hemraj would not let him go inside the house at any cost. He wanted whisky. Hemraj objected to New Comer’s demand. They quarreled silently. But ultimately New Comer entered the house and came down the staircase. Hemraj objected to everything he did in silence. It was past 2.30 am, and Aarushi was still awake in her bedroom, stuck to her computer. She heard something and she came out and murder took place. One other angle is this. When New Comer and Hemraj were on the terrace, Hemraj fell asleep for a while. New Comer saw this as an opportunity to enter the house and came down in search of whisky. At this moment Aarushi came out of her bedroom and New Comer hit her. At this moment Hemraj came down. New Comer hit Hemraj also. Aarushi and Hemraj became unconscious. He drank enough whisky. He slit Aarushi’s throat, took Hemraj on the terrace on the mattress, slit his throat and fled. This is my theory. Uday S. Yadav
sanjaychaura | Mar 07, 2011
someone was after Hemraj, ,his body was badly mutiliated. however Arushi did not suffer this ignonomy. how did this person get in ? there was no need to murder arushi.... how did he get entry in her room...?how did he get control of keys?
guest | Mar 04, 2011
No
amol | Mar 03, 2011
i believe that Nupur is innocent.. did she sleep well that night. was she drugged? did she see her husband in bed all night? did she go for washroom in the night? or her husband? did they have gloves present in the house? did Rajesh drink whiskey anytime,, what occassion does he drink. does Nupur drink too? did Hemraj use to drink? did parents always sleep in night dress? do/did they have sex with each other? the frequency of sex during the last 6 months? how about Hemraj? did Rajesh have sex with anyone else than his wife in his lifetime,, anytime? was Arushi a virgin? was her dad too close to her? did her Dad, anytime kiss his daughter after she crossed 8 years of age?, did Rajesh touch his daughter other than her palms,or hit her anytime after she crossed 8 years of age, anytime? Does Nupur feel that if Rajesh is guilty somehow, that she should never forgive him and ask to get him hanged.. yes sor no?
Asgar | Mar 01, 2011
Give Talwars a chance ,,, there cannot be another new investigation, however there has to be prosecution. let Talwars defend themselves in court. that way they can get the best lawyers and tell the truth.
xyz | Feb 22, 2011
MEDIA is just creating a hype that the talwars have murdered arushi and hemraj ........the people who are agreeing that the talwars have murdered arushi and hemraj are under the influence of the media ....who just spice up the news and assasinate the character of innocent people like the talwars !!! tthe media can go to any extent to make people believe in them at the cost of malining their family to such a great extent ! we hope that god and people have some sympathy on such innocent people .....who have lost their child ...and with it their happiness and reputation .........which they desesrve to get back along with justice for arushi .....and finding the right killers !!!
surya | Feb 22, 2011
The T's are innocent and the cbi needs to wake up and continue with the investigation and finish it off
MURALI029 | Feb 21, 2011
Clear photographs of the terrace through GOOGLE EARTH SEARCH will reveal the identity of the killer. IS THERE SUCH A TECHNIQUE
murali | Feb 21, 2011
If aarushi's cell phone location during the night of her murder is away from her house, as reported in the news that the cell phone was mising,then it can be presumed that the culprit is definitely an outsider. Talwars cannot have sufficient time(3- 4 hours only for day light, because it is summer) to destroy evidence and then throw her cell phone far away. Had they gone out then the watchman or somebody else might have noticed. 2. If there is a technique for retrieving clear photographs of the terrace, where Hemraj's body was found, THROUGH GOOGLE EARTH SEARCH then the culprit's can be known or atleast her father's innocence/ involvement can be proved.
nepali | Feb 21, 2011
catch the gurkha and get tests conducted on him. he might be the culprit too.
murali029 | Feb 20, 2011
I feel arushi's father/ parents have not killed her for the following simple reasons: 1. Police and CBI are well trained, extremely intelligent and have lot of experience .So they can extract truth if someone is accused and interrogated by them, even if evidence is destroyed. No body can lie before them. Not even the greatest actor in this world can lie without being caught. 2. Even if her father/parents have killed her in a fit of rage, they would have repented and confessed their crime and I am sorry to say but I feel they ( for that matter any parent would) have comitted suicide out of remorse.They would not have tried to defend thenselves. 3. After the tragedy and insult life for them may be a burden and they may be living only to know the killer. 4. It is said that there is no perfect murder, but it appears that this time the saying is wrong. 5.I hope the case will be solved some day and the nation knows the truth and the culprit is booked.
xyz | Feb 20, 2011
the cbi and the police is guilty to take the blame because they havnt been able to prove themselves so they r targetting arushis parents at the cost of their reputation !!! they can do anything to prove the talwars wrong .....so basically we see that the cbi is very guilty because they havnt found any proof against the parents because they are innocent and now they are faking and blaming the poor parents who have been through so much ....since the past 3 years !! no parent can kill ..his child ..its visible that the parents are in complete trauma ....right from the day they lost their child ...they have been suffering with ..the judicial system blaming them , the attack on dr. talwar , they been through too much inspite of being innocent .......... this clearly proves that ..the indian judicial system is not trustworthy !!!!!!!!!
rajiv | Feb 19, 2011
My only logic is if Hemraj died a violent death why was there not a scratch mark on Nupur or Rajesh..
Poonam | Feb 19, 2011
Unscieitific investigations.Trying to cover up for lack of proper investigations.CBI is putting innocent parents in jail.All I can say is happy family pictures dont lie .Kids with heaps of friends and good academic records have always been nurtured by loving parents.
subbu | Feb 16, 2011
earlier i was thinking it might be Rajesh Talwar, however after getting the facts, that their main door was locked from outside , makes me believe someone from outside may have committed it, ,someone thru craigslist?
Ahmed | Feb 14, 2011
I strongly believe that Dr. Talwar did not kill them. To me the evidence speaks for itself and if a person who understands human psychology they will be able to say that the parents are innocent. Just becuase of circumstantial evidence you cant accuse them. 'Not guilty until proven' thats what I believe!
GSM | Feb 12, 2011
I dont know what the circumstances say, I dont know what the police suspect. But my inherent vision can aver that the eyes of a mother never speak lies. The gulping voice of the father is not dramatic. After why will they stress to complete the case? why cant police conduct the scientific forensic test which may help to track the DNA of the killer due to his touch? I want to take a stone, write these questions on the stone and hot the stone on police, cbi and judge......Justice is not relying on circumstantial evidences and giving verdict to close the case, Justice is voice of truth, the truth has to come out to manifst Justice !
bharti pandita | Feb 11, 2011
I think no (father,mother) can murder their only child.I think some one is plotting against them,i m 100% sure about it bcoz there is no reason.......for killing their lovely daughter.I wish i could be a lawyer ,i would have definitely helped them to come out of this trouble and punish real culprits.
rajan | Feb 11, 2011
if they did then why oppose the closer report?
JAY DEDAVAT | Feb 10, 2011
TOTALLY Disagree with all conclusion above stated because if they want to do this they don,t go with this type of theory ,by profession they are DOCTER FAMILY if they want to do this ,there are so many idas to do that silently ?they have single child .in this case,doubt is on servent and their daily friends who connecton with hemraj lived near by. also servent of their clinc and durrani clinics.duplicate kyes may be there.we all know servents crminal mentality ?Any person sleep in the AC room they cant hear outside voice if they get sleep ,TV and computer may be on whole night its pssible during sleep and also closed when we wake up for bathroom or other reason during sleep we cant hear out side voice in diffrent type of sleep i.e medicine, alchohal,tired sleep.GOD SAVE &HELP THIS FAMILY .
xyz | Feb 10, 2011
I don't believe in this . If Talwar had to murder their daughter they could have done it some were else and tell it an accident. They could have given it a name of sucide any thing would be done. Even if this would not come in front of media. They could have done it very silently.
anjna | Feb 09, 2011
My heart and my soul says that Parents are innocent and are prey of circumstances . They are in shock please help them out for heaven sake every parents should realise these things .God has already punished them please now alow them to live god sake
Rajiv | Jan 27, 2011
It is sad to see people passing judgement. The people who are condemning Rajesh possibly are not parents themselves. If they were they would have never believed that a parent could kill their child. It is a case of botched up investigation by Noida police. The botch up is being covered by their colleagues who are now posted with CBI. If Utsav Sharma wanted to draw attention for speedy justice he should have attacked one of the investigating cops and not Rajesh who is crying foul our the inaction of CBI and is asking for justice for his daughter.
Dr. SC Talwar | Dec 31, 2010
9. The phone of Arushi remained within the vicinity since KK Gautam lived there. 10.“The post-mortem examination of Aarushi was conducted on May 16. The family members of Aarushi returned home at around 5 pm after the post-mortem. Just after returning to the residence, a call was made by the family to the former DSP of UP Police. Thereafter, the former DSP made a call to the Noida-based eye specialist, who in turn made a call on an unknown number. After 10 minutes, the chain of calls was repeated in the reverse order. The eye specialist received a call from the unknown number. Then the eye specialist made the call to former DSP KK Gautam, who, in turn, called the dentist couple.” The CBI source said the conversation came under scanner as the same chain was repeated the next day on May 17. Later on the same day, the former DSP reached the residence of the Talwar family for the ‘courtesy call’ and “the cop in him found the body of domestic help Hemraj”, who till then was being hunted by Noida police. CBI sources point out that the events of May 16 and 17 could not be a mere coincidence and point to the circumstantial evidence against the doctor and the DSP being part of a possible conspiracy. According to sources, the conversations form an uncanny chain and raise questions about the role of the eye specialist. Gautam, incidentally, was no ordinary DSP and enjoyed proximity to powers-that-be in the Uttar Pradesh establishment. He was part of the charmed circle of Noida and often given charge of the functions organised by the ruling party of UP in the national Capital. 11. It’s not a mere coincidence that Gautam stumbles upon the body of hemraj as also exchange of the vaginal swab at the hospital. 12. It also is no coincidence that on 25 July 1998, a police patrol led by Inspector K.K. Gautam, which was passing by, promptly swung into action, took five daily-wage workers -- Salim, Nafeez, Sajid, Nanhe and Farmood to a deserted spot and shot them one by one at point-blank range. 13. Doctor who was forcing one of the servants to confess during narco test also needs to be asked for whom was he/she doing the favour. Cops and Criminals do possess a close bond. 14. There is plenty of further circumstantial evidence and I dare that KK Gautam shall not take a narco-analysis test hiself, for he has lot to hide.
Dr. SC Talwar | Dec 31, 2010
Take note of the role of KK Gautam in the case. Let me put across salient points as under: 1. The Ex-DSP UP Police was living in the vicinity and known to Dr. Talwar 2. . Hem raj feared a serious threat to his life and yet chose to go to Ms Usha Thakur, a social activist than the police. he further failed to go to police even when prompted to do so by the social activist who herself personally was friendly to KK Gautam, a reason that prompted Hemraj to seek her assistance when he felt threatened by the very cop. Her doing nothing in the matter is unlike a woman and a social activist. 3.Dr. Rajesh Talwar was advised by this cop to take the body to perform last rights urgently or the same could be subjected to further investigation in a MLC. 4. KK Gautam's visit to the place of crime on the heels of departure of Talwar family to Hardwar was to wash any left out evidence which is precisely what was done by the cops instead of preserving the scene of the crime. 5. Sniffer dogs could possibly have given him away, a fact that they were never employed. 6. His juniors who were promoted through his help, did his bidding by washing up any left out evidence. The CBI like in the case of Ruchika, appears to not worry on its crdibility any more. 7. It is said that criminal always returns to the site of crime. The 'cop within him', discovering the body of Hemraj does not gel. 8. Arushi who knew him as an uncle in the vicinity never realised that he had set his designs on her, similar to SPS Rathore. Further paras 9 to 14 bext
Priyanka Thakur | Jun 01, 2008
we cannot jump on any conclusion unless any evidences against the talwar's surface out. though, going by whatever little circumstancial details that have come out in this case, it comes across that Dr Takwar could be the possible killer, but still i would prefer to let the dust settle down. it is almost impossible to imagine a dad killing his daughter.
Why not take into account the interview given by Dr. Nupur Talwar who calls herself 'a living dead'? They also wanted CBI probe. The police might have framed them. I myself wrote on the possible links between parental profligacy and the gruesome murder . But I am also doubtful about the role played by the Police in framing the charge against Dr. Talwar.
B N Patil | May 28, 2008
In this country such type of incidents can not happen unless the person under scrutiny is mental wreck which he is not by his well known credentials
We should not come to final conclusion so quickly. I am however in doubt about the role of Aarushi's mother. Whom does she want to save? Her husband or someone else?

Views

Agree Disagree  
Guest
Name
Email Id
Verification Code
Not finding what you are looking for? Search here.