|
| Yes, afcourse dhoni is responsible for everything happened.He was overconfident.The great & the biggest mistake is that he replaced yuvraj by Ravinder Jadeja............. |
|
| Lekhana : Jun 22, 2009 |
|
|
|
| yes, dhoni is responsible for india exit |
|
| syed junaid : Jun 21, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Dhoni is the only man who should be held responsible for the lose in T20world cup. Coz he is overconfident & busy getting tied up with his ads. |
|
| Kiran Kumar : Jun 20, 2009 |
|
|
|
| no comments |
|
| alkesh bondrea : Jun 19, 2009 |
|
|
|
| he should not to play on one down |
|
| alkesh bondre : Jun 19, 2009 |
|
|
|
| he should not to play on one down |
|
| alkesh bondre : Jun 19, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Mr.Dhoni had made many mistakes right through the series and his current from also contributed for exit of indian team from t20 world cup. He is not up to the mark with both bat and with gloves, he came at number three and has bockdown in 3 matches not able to rotate the strike or hit big ones when required. and with the gloves he was extra ordinary not able to pick up throw from the fielders. mainly due to him not taking right dicision at right time india is out of the T20 world Cup. in my opinion i think Dhoni should be given rest for the upcoming Windies Tour and a young member like Gautam or Bhajji should be the captian of indian team. Who Has very cool head on his shoulders. |
|
| Chetan Patel : Jun 19, 2009 |
|
|
|
| due to lack of proper judgement after winning the toss, Dhoni has choosen fielding and selecting players on 3rd down during batting period resulting to loose of the game. |
|
| Babulal Seth : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| ya dhoni make this mistake from a long time after some break .his dicision is not good in last moments so we want to say plz take out mr. dhoni from indian team for 5 and 6 match. and don't give the captain ship for a long time, this responsible should be given to yuvraj singh. |
|
| devendra pal : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| yes dhoni is responsible for india come out from t20 match.becouse he give the chance of ishant sharma and ravindra jadeja in place of irfan pathand and p.ojha. |
|
| sarvjeet : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Yes. |
|
| sudhir : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
|
|
| adi : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| yes he is only responsible. |
|
| adi : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Dhoni has failed as a Captain / Leader as well player. Team selection was poor as well field strategy was missing. Dhoni was batting worst than the bowler/tailenders. |
|
| Vinod : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| harijith bhai kis duniya mein rahte hain.
Only dhoni is responsilbe for ICC t20 exit. His poor captaincy and batting caused to india defeat. He should be now kept out of the team. |
|
| rajiv tensionable : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| dhoni is responsible |
|
| shanawaz kahan : Jun 16, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Yes, Dhoni is responsible for India's defeat. Dhoni's fault and his bad captaincy cost India the most important match, He was over confident, he was cheater. |
|
| Romi : Jun 16, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Yes Dhoni is the one person who is responsible for India's Bad performance in the T20 WC.He was over confident and due to which India suffered.In the match against English player he has done major mistakes like not to complete RP singh's quota of 4 overs,Over confidence on Ishant Sharma,Sending Jadeja before Yuvi .Yuvi is the only player who is striking the ball very hard in this tournament but he was just the spectator till the comletion of 11 Overs.When captain came he was struggling to hit the balls even struggling for singles.I thought these are the major mistakes which cannot be tolerated in the even in domestic matches.I hope he will concentrate on his game rather than involving in media controversies and earning money from Advertizements.He should realise that he is not playing cricket for making money but playing it for the proud of country and it's one billion cricket crazy peoples.It's really very disheartening to see that Indian team was looking lazy in fielding,bowling & batting in most part of the tournament.How person like Dhoni make such type of silly mistakes. |
|
| Arun Modgil : Jun 16, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Yes Dhoni is the one person who was responsible for India's Bad performance in the T20 WC.He was over confident and due to whcih India suffer.In the match against English player he has done major mistakes like not to complete RP singh's quota of 4 overs,Over confidence on Ishant Sharma,Sending Jadeja before Yuvi .Yuvi is the only player who is striking the ball very hard in this tournament but he was just the spectator till the comletion of 11 Overs.When captain come he was struggling to hit the balls even struggling for singles.I thought these are the major mistakes which cannot be tolerated in the domestic matches.I hope he will concentrate on his game rather than involving in media controversies and earning money from Advertizements.He should relaise that he is not playing cricket for making money but playing it for the proud of country and it's one billion cricket crazy peoples.It's really very disheartening to see that Indian cricketer were looking lazy in fielding,bowling & batting in most part of the tournament. |
|
| Arun Sharma : Jun 16, 2009 |
|
|
|
| yes. Nothing more to say! |
|
| Deepak Dogra : Jun 16, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Yes, Dhoni is responsible for India's defeat. His attitude was selfish. He did not give chance to others in practice matches. He was never comfortable in hitting 4's & 6's and is no more suited for 20-20 matches. I think he has lost his Cricketing common sense and need to take rest from Cricket and Advertisements. |
|
| Nitin : Jun 15, 2009 |
|
|
|
| It was only and only Dhoni's fault and his bad captaincy cost India the most important match. He should understand that everytime luck wont work. This time it was over confidence,arrogance and bad captainship, nothing else. I still fail to understand why did he send Jadeja ahead of everyone. |
|
| Vidhya N : Jun 15, 2009 |
|
|
|
|
| well...2 begin with- for all those who say that dhoni shld no longer b captain nd some1 with a cool head lyk gambhir or yuvi shd bcom captain...get your facts right..!! gambhir is 1 of da most hot-headed batsmen in the indian side..how cn he make a ''cool-headed'' captain...nd as 4 yuvi..he first needs 2 get himself on track b4 he cn lead da whole team...!! dhoni hs been 1 of indias best captains...it ws under his leadership dat india won da T20..den every1 ws ok with his captaincy..bt now that they have lost he shuld b changed..?? india hs lost not bcoz of dhoni or ne1 bt bcoz dey havent got ne tym 2 rest or practice as a team...bcoz of the IPL..b4 dat another tournament nd so on..nd no other team has played so much dis season!! nd cummon...every1 needs a break!!nd where his captaincy nd team seection is concerned...none of us hv a right 2 make comments coz we dont evn noe under what circumstances he has taken dese decisions or 4 what reasonshalf of da ppl who AGREE i bet dont evn noe nething abt cricket on di inside..as in off da feild...i being a ranji player noe what it is lyk 2 be a captain as i hav captained da ranji U-19 team nd its not easy...at times u cm across such decisions which u culdnt evn hv dreamed of..!! as a captain dhoni hs done his job...bt as a team india hasent performed..nd if the team cannot support him despite his best efforts den its not his fault.....i think dey all need a break..!!
|
|
| lee : Jun 25, 2009 |
|
|
|
| well...2 begin with- for all those who say that dhoni shld no longer b captain nd some1 with a cool head lyk gambhir or yuvi shd bcom captain...get your facts right..!! gambhir is 1 of da most hot-headed batsmen in the indian side..how cn he make a ''cool-headed'' captain...nd as 4 yuvi..he first needs 2 get himself on track b4 he cn lead da whole team...!! dhoni hs been 1 of indias best captains...it ws under his leadership dat india won da T20..den every1 ws ok with his captaincy..bt now that they have lost he shuld b changed..?? india hs lost not bcoz of dhoni or ne1 bt bcoz dey havent got ne tym 2 rest or practice as a team...bcoz of the IPL..b4 dat another tournament nd so on..nd no other team has played so much dis season!! nd cummon...every1 needs a break!!nd where his captaincy nd team seection is concerned...none of us hv a right 2 make comments coz we dont evn noe under what circumstances he has taken dese decisions or 4 what reasonshalf of da ppl who AGREE i bet dont evn noe nething abt cricket on di inside..as in off da feild...i being a ranji player noe what it is lyk 2 be a captain as i hav captained da ranji U-19 team nd its not easy...at times u cm across such decisions which u culdnt evn hv dreamed of..!! as a captain dhoni hs done his job...bt as a team india hasent performed..nd if the team cannot support him despite his best efforts den its not his fault.....i think dey all need a break..!!
|
|
| lee : Jun 25, 2009 |
|
|
|
| i think tht the entire indian team is responsible for this. A captain only can make some changes but the other batsman should perform their duty either they are bowler or batsman.
Captian will not handle their bat or ball on the ground. He can only give some clues to them.
If he does not give a chance to Jadeja or RP singh. how we can figure out the situation. Dhoni has done one mistake tht he did out to Irfan Pathan in last two matches. i think he deserve to play instead of Ishant Sharma. |
|
| Raw : Jun 21, 2009 |
|
|
|
| i totally disagree with it |
|
| nav : Jun 21, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Its really gr88 to see people, giving their opinions abt weather they should bat first or ball, If india would have won the match then NOO qs.. every one will say.. very gud decisiion,, very gud experiment..
And suddenly things changes when we lost the match.. and 10000 new opinions..
We can say its a bad day for INDIA, nothing else.. We can say why not rohit sharma, gautam played well.. why yuvraj played a silly shot..
So, u can make many qs out of this..
Blaming sumone is not the right move.. and that too in this Cricket match where SA beat australia chasing a score of 430 approx..
So, nothing can be sure.. many times experiments works and many time not..
But we r very luck as most of the time, experiments worked for us..
Jai hind |
|
| Piyush Rawat : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Well, its gr88 to see people, giving all blames.. that he had done sum experiments and they all failed..
And these are those people, who were very happy .. when hos experiments ver sucessful. Why people havent raised any Qs when his all experiments are successful.. Is he a GOD to give 100% accuracys in all his experiments.
Its a game we win and we loose.. I guess most of the time his experiments were sucessful..
Well anyone said. he is over confidence,, now how can u say that???.. their is a very thin line between confidence and over confidence,,
i guess sending jadeja is okay.. he made.. 25 in 34 balls, and give sum break in the falling wickets..
I agree at last dhoni was slow and he didnt played his natural game, but might be players are throwing gud line balls..
Its not like.. dhoni is responsible,,
And he is always famous for that experiments and they worked most of the time also... if now it flow then we can consider this.. rather then throwing rockcts on him..
tk care
jai hind |
|
| Piyush Rawat : Jun 17, 2009 |
|
|
|
| Ravidra jadeja is responsible for india's earlier exit |
|
| Harijith : Jun 16, 2009 |
|
|
|
Agree- 22
Disagree-7
